• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Kuldeep yadav vs Brad Hogg

Who is better ODI bowler?

  • Total voters
    29
Nintendo

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Kuldeeps transformation has been interesting. Very rarely see a bowler like him get figured out, then add 5-10 km's and come back better than ever.
 
Silver Silva

Silver Silva

International Regular
Saket1209 said:
Yeah because he has already achieved what Hogg achieved in his entire career. Now as Kuldeep has a lot of games left, he will past go him to become the greatest chinaman.
Click to expand...
Brad Hogg has won two world cups and a champions trophy (Basically 3 World Cups since all the teams who can realistically win a WC compete in it) , Kuldeep Yadav has won nothing yet. Brad Hogg took 34 WC wickets at 19 , Kuldeep has 11 wickets in WC @ 41 ..He's still a rookie in comparison to Brad Hogg
 
Saket1209

Saket1209

State Vice-Captain
Silver Silva said:
Brad Hogg has won two world cups and a champions trophy (Basically 3 World Cups since all the teams who can realistically win a WC compete in it) , Kuldeep Yadav has won nothing yet. Brad Hogg took 34 WC wickets at 19 , Kuldeep has 11 wickets in WC @ 41 ..He's still a rookie in comparison to Brad Hogg
Click to expand...
Why do you bring WC win while comparing player. WC is won by a team and it has nothing to do with a player calliber.
SO according to u SREESANTH> CURTLY AMBROSE OR DALE STEYN OR RICHARD HADLEE
And to counter your second point Kuldeep was at his lowest in 2019 and 2020 and he has worked on himself and now he is a completely different bolwer. Just wait and watch his wc records this year.
 
Saket1209

Saket1209

State Vice-Captain
TheJediBrah said:
Jimmy Anderson the best fast bowler of all time too
Click to expand...
No because apart from Longetivity he doesn't have anything in his favour. But for kuldeep their stats are more or less same and then kuldeep has so many years left. So basically he has longetivity plus everything Hogg has. So Kuldeep> Hogg
 
Nintendo

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Saket1209 said:
Why do you bring WC win while comparing player. WC is won by a team and it has nothing to do with a player calliber.
SO according to u SREESANTH> CURTLY AMBROSE OR DALE STEYN OR RICHARD HADLEE
And to counter your second point Kuldeep was at his lowest in 2019 and 2020 and he has worked on himself and now he is a completely different bolwer. Just wait and watch his wc records this year.
Click to expand...
He bought it up cause Hogg has a great wc record and played a part in AUS winning two world cups while kuldeep has a poor wc record and hasn't won anything? This could change if India win this WC, but given their similiar records, using WC performance as a measuring stick to stack them up seems fair.
 
Saket1209

Saket1209

State Vice-Captain
Nintendo said:
He bought it up cause Hogg has a great wc record and played a part in AUS winning two world cups while kuldeep has a poor wc record and hasn't won anything? This could change if India win this WC, but given their similiar records, using WC performance as a measuring stick to stack them up seems fair.
Click to expand...
SO brian lara is the worst player. Doesn't have a wc and didn't performed great in wc.
 
TheJediBrah

TheJediBrah

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Saket1209 said:
No because apart from Longetivity he doesn't have anything in his favour. But for kuldeep their stats are more or less same and then kuldeep has so many years left. So basically he has longetivity plus everything Hogg has. So Kuldeep> Hogg
Click to expand...
Flawless reasoning
 
Saket1209

Saket1209

State Vice-Captain
Nintendo said:
He bought it up cause Hogg has a great wc record and played a part in AUS winning two world cups while kuldeep has a poor wc record and hasn't won anything? This could change if India win this WC, but given their similiar records, using WC performance as a measuring stick to stack them up seems fair.
Click to expand...
WC Wins comes by a team not alone. Even Munaf patel has a wc and has got wickets that doesn't mean he is better than marshall who was quite ordinary in wc. A player should be judged by his performance not by his team. If that was the case then all players from england are garbage becasue they haven't won till 2019
 
TheJediBrah

TheJediBrah

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Saket1209 said:
WC Wins comes by a team not alone. Even Munaf patel has a wc and has got wickets that doesn't mean he is better than marshall who was quite ordinary in wc. A player should be judged by his performance not by his team. If that was the case then all players from england are garbage becasue they haven't won till 2019
Click to expand...
I don't see the issue

Also they technically still haven't won
 
Nintendo

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Saket1209 said:
SO brian lara is the worst player. Doesn't have a wc and didn't performed great in wc.
Click to expand...
Did I say or imply that? Just saying performance on the highest stage seems a good way to compare players with otherwise similiar records. Don't think that's a controversial take, is it?
 
Saket1209

Saket1209

State Vice-Captain
Nintendo said:
Did I say or imply that? Just saying performance on the highest stage seems a good way to compare players with otherwise similiar records. Don't think that's a controversial take, is it?
Click to expand...
It can be a good take to compare players on their wc performance but not the team wc performance. But a player can not only be judged on one parameter. And you are trying to prove your point on the basis of just Hogg WC performance. And Kuldeep can play another wc who knows his record can be better than that of Hogg.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top