• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* Australia vs South Africa -2022/3

Starfighter

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Aaron Hardie probably the best choice. no way they bat agar at 6/7, he's not good enough with the bat.
Hardie's the only choice I can think of, though he's been poor with bat and ball in the Shield (26 bat, 44 bowl).

Agar is not got enough in either discipline and shouldn't be anywhere near anything but the T20I side. And Sydney hasn't spun for fifteen years.
 

ashley bach

Cricketer Of The Year
Yep i edited to reflect, Aaron hardie. Good stats overall, batting ave of 45 in shield is fine. at age of 23, same age as green, and both very tall, Hardie is 193cm, a like for like swap.

Both green and starc, will take several weeks to recover from finger injuries. those are long recovery times.

This test will slowly meander to a draw, as australia have only 2 pace bowlers left, on an absolute road of a pitch.
Mate back the draw @20/1 if you think it's meandering that way...money for old rope right?
 
Last edited:

Spark

Global Moderator
Aus only have three bowlers right now, but SA could well be physically cooked by then. Rough old day
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
So we are potentially going to get 2 potential Debuts at the SCG, Lance Morris(or Todd Murphy if the SCG spins) and Aaron Hardie

Murphy won’t play unless Lyon gets hurt. No way they pick two offies.

A lot will depend on whether they sew up the series here. If they do they might go in a batsman light and Carey will bat six and Agar seven.
 

Son Of Coco

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
yeah they should trial him in test cricket in place of the injured starc. trialling jhye worked really well. morris is like jhye and audiences go gaga over jhye.

Starc confirmed injury and i believe he is out for sydney- almost no recovery time

Neser/Haze arent like for like selections. Haze bowls around 138-140 range, neser around 130kph.


Also haze should take the place of Boland for SCG, being NSW- he is more familiar with the track, i think boland should only play on green tops or swinging conditions, not the best on flat decks.
Considering Boland doesn't really swing it, why would you play him in swinging conditions?
 

The_CricketUmpire

U19 Captain
Top 20 Runscorers - Australian Batsman in the Opening Position: Number 1 / Number 2

PlayerSpanMatInnsNORunsDescendingHSAve100500
ML Hayden1994-200910318414862538050.73302914investigate this query
DA Warner2011-202210018098083335*47.26253412investigate this query
MA Taylor1989-1999104186137525334*43.4919405investigate this query
MJ Slater1993-2001741317531221942.8314219investigate this query
WM Lawry1961-19716712312523421047.1513276investigate this query
JL Langer1993-2007651159511225048.2216187investigate this query
RB Simpson1960-196838704366431155.518193investigate this query
AR Morris1946-195545762338120645.6811124investigate this query
CC McDonald1952-196147813307317039.395172investigate this query
GM Wood1978-198551924295817233.618127investigate this query
SM Katich2008-201033613292815750.488172investigate this query
GR Marsh1985-199250917281913833.554153investigate this query
DC Boon1985-199336635261420045.068105investigate this query
IR Redpath1964-1976325932492159*44.506152investigate this query
KR Stackpole1969-197433645239020740.506144investigate this query
SR Watson2009-201329522204912640.982153investigate this query
WM Woodfull1926-193427444203616150.907114investigate this query
CJL Rogers2008-201525481201517342.875141investigate this query
W Bardsley1909-1926334751755193*41.784114investigate this query
VT Trumper1901-191232522165015933.00395
 
Last edited:

Starfighter

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Murphy won’t play unless Lyon gets hurt. No way they pick two offies.

A lot will depend on whether they sew up the series here. If they do they might go in a batsman light and Carey will bat six and Agar seven.
I hate the idea in your second paragraph, which certainly increases the chances they'll do it.

Sydney hasn't spun for years and pace over spin is the better option unless it looks like a 2000-era pitch. Agar is a poor bowler.

I'd go for someone who can bat. Seen the idea floated of Neser batting higher, but IMO he's not good enough. Don't need to be making the same mistake as the opposition.
 

halba

International 12th Man
Considering Boland doesn't really swing it, why would you play him in swinging conditions?
Neser and Morris imho. for ashes squad at least. then they will pick based on the deck. Boland is seamer i agree. Haze is injury prone is an issue. Will Jhye be available for selection @ ashes, he would be a handful if he's ever fit..
 

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Also, why on earth are people going "WhERe GOinG to STruggLE To BOwL SA oUT." There's 3 days left in the test, we already have a significant lead and they don't have a bat who averages north of 40.
 

Top