TheJediBrah
Request Your Custom Title Now!
How is it a different argument? ATG team will still have to field won't it?I wouldn't be opposed to having guys like Symonds/Rhodes/Ponting/Gibbs(apart from that choke ) in the top 6 just for their fielding tbh but it's a different argument though.
Also you still need the player to be ATG standard on their primary skills alone for consideration, which Rhodes and Gibbs are probably not quite. Symonds and Ponting though would be close-ish to selection regardless of fielding.
Alternatively maybe you could pick Symonds as 12th man and just have him field the whole time a la Gary Pratt . . .