thierry henry
International Coach
My biggest problem with this was it just wasn't out. Honestly reckon that's an absolute stinker from the 3rd umpire.
-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
2016 Under 19 Cricket World Cup
- Thread starter SeamUp
- Start date
+1
Suggest Shimron Hetmyer googles "paul collingwood poor sportsmanship". He may then realise that he's probably lost his chance of captaincy at higher levels. Although with the current WI administration who knows ...
Franco Vazquez
Banned
I agree.If Holder can captain a Test team then even Hetmyer shouldn't be hopeless
Why? We have third and 4th umpires who can check it.
hendrix
Hall of Fame Member
every single delivery?
They have a mic to the umpires on the field. There should be more then enough time for them to see and let the umpires know before the next ball is bowled.
Last edited:
Franco Vazquez
Banned
It was in the crease when the bails dislodged first but he gradually walked which led his bat to get on the line
hendrix
Hall of Fame Member
if that were the case it should be not out and the 3rd umpire made an incorrect decision.
Franco Vazquez
Banned
His bat was on the line when the bails were completely off
hendrix
Hall of Fame Member
yeah that's one law they might look at fixing, as Bahnz mentioned. The fact that the batsman is moving in the reverse direction to a normal run-out should afford some different application.
TBH I think all runout laws should be changed so that it's as soon as the ball/hand holding the ball makes contact with the wickets. It's way too hard to tell the exact moment the bail is completely off the stumps.
Franco Vazquez
Banned
So we will see Namibia making their TV debut in U19 WC.I think India should bat first against them and score 400+
Franco Vazquez
Banned
Yes initially
wellAlbidarned
International Coach
i need to see a ****ing video
hendrix
Hall of Fame Member
just travel to the UK and go on the cricinfo commentary
Chubb
International Regular
Pretty appalled.
My opinion of Mankading is similar to most people, I'd imagine. Have no problem with it as long as there is a warning first. I had no sympathy for Jos Buttler. I am aware this is not a particularly rational argument.
There was no attempt at a warning in this case. The bowler has robbed the people at the ground, and those watching on TV, of an exciting finish to a keenly contested match. He has also robbed his teammates and himself of the chance to know whether they could have pulled off a win without Mankading, even if they don't realise that yet. And the way they celebrated was immature but I suppose you can't expect much more of U19s.
On the other hand, Zimbabwe should have won without needing a last wicket stand.
My opinion of Mankading is similar to most people, I'd imagine. Have no problem with it as long as there is a warning first. I had no sympathy for Jos Buttler. I am aware this is not a particularly rational argument.
There was no attempt at a warning in this case. The bowler has robbed the people at the ground, and those watching on TV, of an exciting finish to a keenly contested match. He has also robbed his teammates and himself of the chance to know whether they could have pulled off a win without Mankading, even if they don't realise that yet. And the way they celebrated was immature but I suppose you can't expect much more of U19s.
On the other hand, Zimbabwe should have won without needing a last wicket stand.
Black_Warrior
Cricketer Of The Year
And they defended 212. Proud of you boys 