I had some free time today and had googled this whole saga and I gotta say I totally take Joni's side on this one. Whatever happened at text gate and prior should have all been forgotten about once KP was asked to come back to help win a series in India and consolidate Cook as the captain. That said,a few pointers based on everything I read on this issue today:
- Very bad idea for Swann to write **** about KP in his book while they were still team mates and still had a few more years to go to retirement.
- While Andy Flower did publically condemn that the book was released, I guess KP expected more **** to be thrown at Swann for that transgression by Strauss and Flower, at least inside the team environment.
- Looks like there was a band of bullies in the English dressing room who enjoyed teasing the **** out of KP (coz he was a ****) a lot of the time - guessing it was Broad, Anderson, Swann.
- The guys following the KP parody account and apparently leaking stuff KP says or does inside the dressing room must have been the last straw for a guy with a big ego like KP.
- His frustrations at Strauss and Flower may have stemmed from his perspective that they were more strict with him than they were with the bullies club and may have led to the stupid stupid texts he sent out to the South African players.
- Very interesting that his texts were leaked while I am sure the less than complimentary texts about him that other team members might have floated around never made the light.
- The decision to sack him over the textgate scandal was totally justified and more time should have been given to all parties to bury the hatchet. Instead he was hurried back because Cook wanted to win in India badly.
- The team environment under Flower had become intolerable for someone like KP with all the planning and sucking the enjoyment out of playing the game. And when he spoke out, all the hidden animosities between them came out to the open again and Cook and Prior, both of whom KP might have trusted when he got back into the team in India, totally sold him out to the coach.
So given this is how this story seems to have played out (at least from the public accounts) I am totally of the opinion that once he was "reintegrated" there was nothing that KP really did apart from speak out against what he thought was bad coaching philosophy and he really does not deserve to be sacked for being a dick, coz there are many of the same in this current England set up. It is just that he is a dick the other dicks do not like. Heck, we are seeing interviews even today where Bell and Broad are saying they have no problems with him being in the side. What a joke!!!
Gotta say, the biggest role played here must be by the ECB (read Giles Clarke), who have had such a bad relationship with KP that the moment there was opportunity to knock him down and get him out of English cricket, they did it, THRICE!!!