Furball
Evil Scotsman
KP described him as the obvious replacement for Michael Vaughan, so you would assume so - although like I said, KP was the only player assured of his place in all 3 formats whereas Collingwood's Test place was by no means assured.
You'd also have had the funny scenario of announcing Collingwood as captain across all 3 formats then immediately sitting out 3 ODIs due to a ban
In hindsight it should have gone to Strauss although by the sounds of it whoever was given the gig would've been in for a difficult time as Peter Moores was apparently difficult to work with. Pietersen getting the captaincy and getting rid of Moores may have been a necessary evil to pave the way for what we saw under Strauss and Flower.
You'd also have had the funny scenario of announcing Collingwood as captain across all 3 formats then immediately sitting out 3 ODIs due to a ban
In hindsight it should have gone to Strauss although by the sounds of it whoever was given the gig would've been in for a difficult time as Peter Moores was apparently difficult to work with. Pietersen getting the captaincy and getting rid of Moores may have been a necessary evil to pave the way for what we saw under Strauss and Flower.