*Official* Redemption Part 2 at Adelaide

[benchmark00]

For the Carlton mid MOTM comp I had NCN and McKay among my selections...

 

[Pothas]

Well I can't think of a worse end to a tour, anyone but Watson.

 

[Dan]

Legit never seen that before. Wade you arsey ****.

Graham Manou stumped someone with his gut once, IIRC.

 

[wpdavid]

And there you have it. Sums up the whole tour really. Really, you'd have fancied Bangladesh to finish this match off from where we were an hour ago.

 

[GIMH]

Are the English commentators seriously saying that stumping wasn't out?

I thought it was out when you're not in the crease and the bails are removed...

Lloyd said he thought it was probably out, actually. But how anyone could say that the bail was definitely fully dislodged before his foot came down is beyond me.

 

[flibbertyjibber]

Are the English commentators seriously saying that stumping wasn't out?

I thought it was out when you're not in the crease and the bails are removed...

Muted it to not hear it.

Now turned over as they bound to moan.

 

[GIMH]

No sorry that decision stinks.

 

[benchmark00]

Lloyd said he thought it was probably out, actually. But how anyone could say that the bail was definitely fully dislodged before his foot came down is beyond me.

Maybe because there was a camera there documenting it? I'm not sure what Sky was showing but 9 had a split screen of the bail coming off and the foot in the air. It was definitive.

 

[GIMH]

Muted it to not hear it.

Now turned over as they bound to moan.

Noted Englishman Greg Blewett thinks it was a stinker of a decision ftr

 

[flibbertyjibber]

No sorry that decision stinks.

Past caring, whole tour been a farce so not worth getting upset over.

 

[Spark]

Maybe because there was a camera there documenting it? I'm not sure what Sky was showing but 9 had a split screen of the bail coming off and the foot in the air. It was definitive.

You could only see half the bail though.

 

[GIMH]

Maybe because there was a camera there documenting it? I'm not sure what Sky was showing but 9 had a split screen of the bail coming off and the foot in the air. It was definitive.

Watching that split screen now. For me the bail isn't fully dislodged before his foot comes down - or not certainly anyway.

Don't think we would have won anyway ftr

 

[Top_Cat]

Was under the impression only half the bail had to be out of its groove, tbh.

 

[Spikey]

I thought it was gonna be given not out, on benefit of the doubt, ftr

 

[grecian]

Past caring, whole tour been a farce so not worth getting upset over.

Not over yet, we've still some losing to do in the t20s. At least they're over quickly.

 

[Spikey]

this is making me think of those ****ing zing bails staying on the Thunder match earlier this season

 

[Dan]

Maybe because there was a camera there documenting it? I'm not sure what Sky was showing but 9 had a split screen of the bail coming off and the foot in the air. It was definitive.

Yeah the reverse-angle camera looked about as conclusive as you can get.

Though if Channel 9 did things in HD, it would be completely indisputable. Or use the ZING(TM) bails.

 

[GIMH]

Was under the impression only half the bail had to be out of its groove, tbh.

Bumble saying it has to be fully dislodged

 

[Top_Cat]

Was under the impression only half the bail had to be out of its groove, tbh.

Law 28 (The Wicket is down)

Hmmm.

 

[benchmark00]

Was under the impression only half the bail had to be out of its groove, tbh.

Yeah not sure where this other interpretation has come from.