Pakistan Cricket news/views

[Jager]

The selection of Kamran Akmal, arguably the worst keeper most have seen in their lifetime, would bring shame on the team.

 

[smash84]

The selection of Kamran Akmal, arguably the worst keeper most have seen in their lifetime, would bring shame on the team.

Try explaining this to Loser Z-Man

 

[Z-Man]

Try explaining this to Loser Z-Man

Keep in mind that I am arguing for Kamran only in T20 and purely based on talent & stats. One can not argue against the immense potential he has as a batsmen and perhaps a keeper. I remember when he entered the team in place of Moin Khan, he was the 'next' big thing.
I think most of us Remember the famous India v Pak test where he single-handedly won the game.

So the potential is certainly there but the hatred has increased so much that people tend to forget that he has the most potential in domestic cricket. We saw that in T20 Faysal Bank tournament as well.
In Pakistan, we require an explosive opening batsmen and Kamran is one of them. Other option is to bring in Imran Nazir and play Umar as a keeper.

 

[Z-Man]

Just found this in PP. Next to Gilchrist in terms of dismissals per innings. Not a bad choice eh?

 

[unam]

Just found this in PP. Next to Gilchrist in terms of dismissals per innings. Not a bad choice eh?

this despite dropping 80 + catches in last few years, would have probably taken some of those dropped catches later on.

I would still not want him to be the keeper

There is no point in dropping a batsman on 0 then take his catch when he has already scored 100, doesn't matter how hard/beautiful the catch is.

 

[smash84]

There is no point in dropping a batsman on 0 then take his catch when he has already scored 100, doesn't matter how hard/beautiful the catch is.

AWTA

Also These stats do not show how many he dropped and how far ahead of the table he would have been had he caught on to those 86 chances.

Add those 86 chances and his ratio becomes 2.95.

Those 86 missed dismissals also means that for every 5 catches he caught he dropped 2

I can't imagine a worse keeper in history

 

[Z-Man]

Yet this shows that Kamran is still better than the lot we have in our domestic and international i.e Sarfaraz,Adnan and Umar.

My point still holds. Kamran deserves to be ahead of the other 3 as a "keeper batsmen" in T20 international.

 

[Z-Man]

AWTA



Those 86 missed dismissals also means that for every 5 catches he caught he dropped 2

I can't imagine a worse keeper in history

Bring Umar Akmal in equation. He took 3 catches and dropped/shuffled 2 potential stumps + a drop chance in a couple of English matches.

Sarfaraz and Adnan do not count since their batting is not up to mark for T20.

 

[unam]

Yet this shows that Kamran is still better than the lot we have in our domestic and international i.e Sarfaraz,Adnan and Umar.

My point still holds. Kamran deserves to be ahead of the other 3 as a "keeper batsmen" in T20 international.

As a batsman YES as a keeper NO. OVERALL NO

 

[smash84]

As a batsman YES as a keeper NO. OVERALL NO

This

 

[Z-Man]

How! In T20, he still is a better choice than Kamran.
Take out all the hatred from your mind and think with a cool mind.

In T20 he is a better batsmen than Adnan and Co where as he is a better keeper than Umar.
Shan't he get a nod ahead of others?

 

[Prince EWS]

You really don't/shouldn't need that much proper batting depth in T20 cricket and part-time bowlers are still effective on a lot of surfaces, so it's one format where you should be able to pick a genuine keeper pretty much all of the time, even if your bloke isn't an international standard batsman.

If he's one of the best T20 batsmen available then pick him as a batsman by all means but leave the gloves with someone who can catch.

 

[unam]

You really don't/shouldn't need that much proper batting depth in T20 cricket and part-time bowlers are still effective on a lot of surfaces, so it's one format where you should be able to pick a genuine keeper pretty much all of the time, even if your bloke isn't an international standard batsman.

If he's one of the best T20 batsmen available then pick him as a batsman by all means but leave the gloves with someone who can catch.

we can't even pick him as a batsman because then he will bring his dirty politics with him and will screw up the atmosphere of dressing room again.

 

[Z-Man]

 

[smash84]

haha....thanks so much PEWS....you rid us of Z-Man

 

[Agent Nationaux]

I would rather have Adnan as keeper even though he is a **** batsman. He is a really good keeper and will save us the need to get another 2-3 wickets thanks to junior or kami's dropmals.

 

[Xuhaib]

Just found this in PP. Next to Gilchrist in terms of dismissals per innings. Not a bad choice eh?

this table is more of a testament of Pakistani bowlers skills then Kakmal keeping skills.

 

[smash84]

that is another thing I had thought about

 

[Yas]

Still think Sarfraz is the best option ATM has a decent batting technique that can be worked on and hasn't had ne clangers so far (I think!). Adnan is fine for tests. Always surprised me we haven't been able to find an odi keeper as ive always believed you need someone who can catch a ball and have the ability to play a few shots lower down the order, yet we can't even find someone to do that :-(

 

[salman85]

Sarfaraz deserves a chance.He's been in out of the team off and on.He's had a good Asia Cup,and we need to persist with him for some time to get the best out of him.