Would Stuart Broad make India's strongest test XI?

[Burgey]

srinath ishant sree pk munaf etc etc.

my turn, name one aussie spinner after warne better than virender sehwag pl

MacGill. Miller. Matthews. All way better. I'm limiting it to post-1990 there. Plainly if we went way back there would be plenty more. Actually, since you're so happy to talk about spinners, name me one from India, Kumble aside, who's had any success in Australia since 1990?

I will grant you Sreensanth. Disagree Prasad was "definitively" better than Broad. Lol Munaf Patel is a joke, Sharma has had one good test in three years, and Praveen Kumar bowls as slow as me - he's your second spinner.

Moreover, the fact there is this thread rather indicates none of those blokes are clearly better than Broad. So please, keep going.

Edit: I left out Tim May as well, apologies.

 

[Bun]

should have worded better myself. I meant since warme retired. anyways I am not interested in arguing further if you think ishanth has had just one good test in three years and patel is a joke.

 

[Burgey]

Patel is a joke. I know this because his and Sharma's places are secured on the Wheel of Mediocrity. If SS says it's so, it's so.

 

[GIMH]

should have worded better myself. I meant since warme retired. anyways I am not interested in arguing further if you think ishanth has had just one good test in three years and patel is a joke.

I've seen you say you're not interested in arguing further in about 500 threads over the last three years and you always pop back up, I don't believe you.

I'd argue, just FTR, that Hauritz is a better spinner than some of your seamers are at their style

 

[Bun]

talking of spin name an australian spin bowler win has a good record in india since days of mallett and benaud???

 

[Howe_zat]

should have worded better myself. I meant since warme retired. anyways I am not interested in arguing further if you think ishanth has had just one good test in three years and patel is a joke.

talking of spin name an australian spin bowler win has a good record in india since days of mallett and benaud???

13 minutes

 

[Prince EWS]

talking of spin name an australian spin bowler win has a good record in india since days of mallett and benaud???

Jason Krejza.

 

[Burgey]

talking of spin name an australian spin bowler win has a good record in india since days of mallett and benaud???

Same as the number of Indian spinners in Australia.

Actually, pretty much the same as the number of all Indian bowlers save Kumble who've done well in Australia to date...

Which would be at or near zilch.

 

[GIMH]

13 minutes

And to think I was cruel enough not to believe him

 

[Howe_zat]

Ooh, ooh, now name a batsman to have scored a century away from home on a Wednesday while going commando.

(Am I doing it right?)

 

[GIMH]

Ooh, ooh, now name a batsman to have scored a century away from home on a Wednesday while going commando.

(Am I doing it right?)

Ian Bell

 

[Burgey]

Ian Bell drinks and smokes
And lends his arse to other

never mind

 

[Bun]

13 minutes

glad each my word is closely kept tabs on.

 

[Bun]

Jason Krejza.

lol...

 

[Burgey]

Jason Krejza.

Good shout.

 

[Prince EWS]

Good shout.

Michael Clarke as well.

 

[Burgey]

Michael Clarke as well.

Much better spinner than Sehwag I reckon.

 

[Spark]

I've seen you say you're not interested in arguing further in about 500 threads over the last three years and you always pop back up, I don't believe you.

I'd argue, just FTR, that Hauritz is a better spinner than some of your seamers are at their style

(y)

---

I miss Clarke's random wicket-taking bowling

 

[Burgey]

(y)

---

I miss Clarke's random wicket-taking bowling

I miss all our bowlers taking wickets..

 

[smash84]

I miss all our bowlers taking wickets..

and I miss our batsman making runs or chasing even modest totals