• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* - India in West Indies

Jacknife

International Captain
I don't know what was said then, when Kholi was dismissed, but that didn't look good, walking up to the umpire and appearing to be arguing the decision, isn't what you want to see, even if it was a poor call.
 

IrishOpener

U19 Debutant
Kohli is given out, Malcom with another HOWLER, this guy is the worst umpire. I know people make mistakes but the level of mistakes he gets wrong is just not acceptable, all through this current series he's made terrible decisions,

is he part of the elite umpires?, :-O...
 

shivfan

Banned
I don't know what was said then, when Kholi was dismissed, but that didn't look good, walking up to the umpire and appearing to be arguing the decision, isn't what you want to see, even if it was a poor call.
Especially when your cricket bosses forced the WICB to abandon plans to use UDRS....

In that case, Indian batsmen should try to accept bad decisions with good grace.
 

IrishOpener

U19 Debutant
I don't know what was said then, when Kholi was dismissed, but that didn't look good, walking up to the umpire and appearing to be arguing the decision, isn't what you want to see, even if it was a poor call.

I completely disagree, this umpire is just shocking, if the ball was missing by an inch then maybe it's not a bad decision but the ball was missing by 6 inches, and he is still allowed umpire, I've never been so annoyed watching cricket then with this umpire,

where is Mr.Dar?, Mr.Dharmasena, etc,

think I'll have to stop watching WI cricket, too many bad decisions, it's ruining a good game, and it's a pity the West Indies can't win without these decisions going their way...
 
Last edited:

Shri

Mr. Glass
Get UDRS you ****s
I completely disagree, this umpire is just shocking, if the ball was missing by an inch then maybe it's not a bad decision but the ball was missing by 6 inches, and he is still allowed umpire, I've never been so annoyed watching cricket then with this umpire,

where is Mr.Dar?, Mr.Dharmasena, etc,

think I'll have to stop watching WI cricket, too many bad decisions, it's ruining a good game, and it's a pity the West Indies can't win without these decisions going their way...
:lol:

Usernames confused me a bit. Genuine wtf moment.:p
 

Howe_zat

Audio File
I completely disagree, this umpire is just shocking, if the ball was missing by an inch then maybe it's not a bad decision but the ball was missing by 6 inches, and he is still allowed umpire, I've never been so annoyed watching cricket then with this umpire,

where is Mr.Dar?, Mr.Dharmasena, etc,

think I'll have to stop watching WI cricket, too many bad decisions, it's ruining a good game, and it's a pity the West Indies can't win without these decisions going their way...
Irrelevant how bad the decision was, you just don't mouth off at the umpire.

I have some sympathy for Kohli so I won't hound him too much for it, but getting a bad decision isn't an excuse.
 

IrishOpener

U19 Debutant
Irrelevant how bad the decision was, you just don't mouth off at the umpire.

I have some sympathy for Kohli so I won't hound him too much for it, but getting a bad decision isn't an excuse.

Well I don't think he should have but had he in this situation then I wouldn't think bad of Kohli, and Malcolm just smiles away, he doesn't care how bad he messes up, I know umpiring isn't the easiest job but Mr.Dar seems to get it right 999/1000...
 

shivfan

Banned
I completely disagree, this umpire is just shocking, if the ball was missing by an inch then maybe it's not a bad decision but the ball was missing by 6 inches, and he is still allowed umpire, I've never been so annoyed watching cricket then with this umpire,

where is Mr.Dar?, Mr.Dharmasena, etc,

think I'll have to stop watching WI cricket, too many bad decisions, it's ruining a good game, and it's a pity the West Indies can't win without these decisions going their way...
UDRS was invented because of umpires like Malcolm....

It's India's fault that they oppose its use. If they oppose the use of UDRS, they should accept the umpire's decisions without question.

For his actions, I hope Kohli is referred to the match referee. Ganguly got sanctioned for far less....
 

Jayzamann

International Regular
I completely disagree, this umpire is just shocking, if the ball was missing by an inch then maybe it's not a bad decision but the ball was missing by 6 inches, and he is still allowed umpire, I've never been so annoyed watching cricket then with this umpire,

where is Mr.Dar?, Mr.Dharmasena, etc,

think I'll have to stop watching WI cricket, too many bad decisions, it's ruining a good game, and it's a pity the West Indies can't win without these decisions going their way...
Please use this as an avatar

 

IrishOpener

U19 Debutant
UDRS was invented because of umpires like Malcolm....

It's India's fault that they oppose its use. If they oppose the use of UDRS, they should accept the umpire's decisions without question.

For his actions, I hope Kohli is referred to the match referee. Ganguly got sanctioned for far less....
I've calmed down now, it's just so sad to see these decisions being made, and true India still will say they don't want UDRS :O...
 

Top