• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

CW's 50 Best ODI Cricketers of all time - The Countdown

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
none of them deserved to be nominated. so fair enough that they didnt get any votes.
I think someone like Yuvraj or Kirsten could be considered as good as the 50th placed Harris.

I was surprised that Vettori didn't get nominated (I might have to double check this) when the likes of Lance Cairns and Ewan Chatfield did.
 

ankitj

Hall of Fame Member
none of them deserved to be nominated. so fair enough that they didnt get any votes.
I will take some of these in place of Chris Harris or Nathan Bracken who made it to top 50.

Nufan, can you also post the 51 to 80 (or whatever) before posting the top 2? Without any bio, just the names and number of votes.
 
Last edited:

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
Again no 30/30. Please name yourself those who didn't select one of the three named cricketers.
Oops, I got lazy with counting the total nominations for the last three players. Wasim is still at 27, McGrath is 29 and Gilchrist was chosen by all 30.

The points are definitely correct, don't stress anyone, just the total noms for these last few players..
 

bagapath

International Captain
no, mate. may be harris. but bracken deserves a place in the top 50. in a batsman dominated era he was as good as any bowler in this format.
 

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
I will take some of these in place of Chris Harris or Nathan Bracken who made it to top 50.

Nufan, can you also post the 51 to 80 (or whatever) before posting the top 2? Without any bio, just the names and number of votes.
Damian Martyn 25 (someone picked him in first)
Matthew Hayden 22
Andrew Flintoff 20
Dennis Lillee 19
Shahid Afridi 18
Herschelle Gibbs 18
Lance Cairns 16
Nathan Astle 15
Ewan Chatfield 15
Virender Sehwag 13
Kevin Pietersen 13
Kumar Sangakarra 9
Marcus Trescothick 9
Shoaib Akhtar 8
Brad Hogg 8
Andy Flower 8
Simon O’Donnell 8
Clive Lloyd 8
Abdul Razzaq 7
Courtney Walsh 7
Shakib Al Hasan 5
Steve Tikolo 4
Chaminda Vaas 4
Allan Lamb 4
Roger Twose 3
Nick Knight 2
Damien Fleming 1
Heath Streak 1
Darren Gough 1
 

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
Okay time for second and first place..

The 50 best ODI Cricketers so far..
50 Chris Harris
49 Chris Gayle
48 Jonty Rhodes
47 Neil Fairbrother
46 AB de Villiers
45 Michael Holding
44 Shane Watson
43 Allan Border
42 Chris Cairns
41 Martin Crowe
40 Malcolm Marshall
39 Nathan Bracken
38 Gordon Greenidge
37 Greg Chappell
36 Mark Waugh
35 Saeed Anwar
34 Desmond Haynes
33 Shane Bond
32 Inzamam-Ul-Haq
31 Aravinda de Silva
30 Brett Lee
29 Sourav Ganguly
28 Michael Hussey
27 Allan Donald
26 Javed Miandad
25 Andrew Symonds
24 MS Dhoni
23 Curtly Ambrose
22 Zaheer Abbas
21 Saqlain Mushtaq
20 Richard Hadlee
19 Lance Klusener
18 Dean Jones
17 Imran Khan
16 Waqar Younis
15 Jacques Kallis
14 Shane Warne
13 Kapil Dev
12 Brian Lara
11 Sanath Jayasuriya
10 Ricky Ponting
9 Shaun Pollock
8 Muttiah Muralitharan
7 Joel Garner
6 Michael Bevan
5 Glenn McGrath
4 Adam Gilchrist
3 Wasim Akram
2 ........................
1 ........................



2 SACHIN TENDULKAR



Sachin Tendulkar | India Cricket | Cricket Players and Officials | ESPN Cricinfo

Total Points 647
Total Nominations 29/30
Highest Rating 1


Tendulkar holds just about every batting record worth owning in the game, including those for most runs and hundreds in ODI’s.

His batting is based on the purest principles: perfect balance, economy of movement, precision in stroke-making, and that intangible quality given only to geniuses: anticipation. If he doesn't have a signature stroke - the upright, back-foot punch comes close - it is because he is equally proficient at each of the full range of orthodox shots (and plenty of improvised ones as well) and can pull them out at will.

There are no apparent weaknesses in Tendulkar's game. He can score all around the wicket, off both front foot and back, can tune his technique to suit every condition, temper his game to suit every situation, and has made runs in all parts of the world in all conditions.

Tendulkar retains a divine enthusiasm for the game, and he seems to be untouched by age: at 36 years and 306 days he broke a 40-year-old barrier by scoring the first double-century in one-day cricket.

Tendulkar's considerable achievements seem greater still when looked at in the light of the burden of expectations he has had to bear from his adoring but somewhat unreasonable followers, who have been prone to regard anything less than a hundred in each innings as a failure. The aura may have dimmed, if only slightly, as the years on the international circuit have taken their toll on the body, but Tendulkar remains, by a distance, the most worshipped cricketer in the world.



1 VIV RICHARDS



Sir Viv Richards | West Indies Cricket | Cricket Players and Officials | ESPN Cricinfo

Total Points 699
Total Nominations 30/30
Highest Rating 1


You knew when he was coming. The outgoing batsman would already have disappeared into the pavilion, and the expectation of what was to follow filled the air. Viv kept you waiting... time to ponder. Then he appeared, sauntering, swaggering, arms windmilling slowly. He would take guard, and then, head tilted back slightly and cudding his gum, he would walk a few paces down the pitch to tap it while looking the bowler in the eye. It was calculated menace and magnificent theatre from arguably the most devastating batsman of all time.

How to bowl to him? Get him to the other end, perhaps. Hold your nerve, do not take what might follow as personal. Occasionally he was vulnerable early on if his desire to dominate overwhelmed him. But he had no weakness until his eyesight infinitesimally but inevitably started to let him down and those eye shots became harder.

His strengths were on the front foot. So far forward could he get that he was able to plant that left foot outside the line of off stump, at once eliminating lbw and creating his own leg stump line from where he would flick bowlers relentlessly through midwicket. Or he might send a similar ball skimming through extra cover. Straighten the ball down the line of the stumps and the bowler stood a chance, but he rarely missed and they ran a terrible risk.

In 1975 Richards helped the West Indies win the inaugural Cricket World Cup, The West Indies were again able to win the following World Cup in 1979, thanks to a Richards century in the final at Lord's.

He was the first Cricketer to score a century and take 5 wickets in the same match and his 189* was rated by Wisden as the best ODI innings of all time.

Richards finished his career with an average of 47 and a phenomenal strike rate for his time of 90. He also took 100 catches and over 100 wickets, making Sir Vivian Richards a most worthy winner in CW's 50 Best ODI Cricketers of all time.
 

bagapath

International Captain
thanks for running the polls nufan. good job.

cant believe one guy in CW didnt find sachin good enough to be in the top 25. that is amazing.

i can live with the final list. viv was one of the greatest batters ever in the history of the game. in my opinion, he is the father of ODI battting. sachin, sanath, sehwag, dhoni, gilly and KP and AB these days owe a lot to the big man for showing them the way.

since there are only two wicket keepers in the top 50 i could only put together two legitimate teams. so here are the first and second xis selected by CW.

tendulkar
gilchrist +
ponting
richards
lara
bevan
pollock
akram
murali
garner
mcgrath


jayasuriya
haynes
kallis
jones
ms dhoni +
klusener
imran
kapildev
hadlee
warne
younis
 
Last edited:

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
CW's 50 Best ODI Cricketers of all time
50 Chris Harris
49 Chris Gayle
48 Jonty Rhodes
47 Neil Fairbrother
46 AB de Villiers
45 Michael Holding
44 Shane Watson
43 Allan Border
42 Chris Cairns
41 Martin Crowe
40 Malcolm Marshall
39 Nathan Bracken
38 Gordon Greenidge
37 Greg Chappell
36 Mark Waugh
35 Saeed Anwar
34 Desmond Haynes
33 Shane Bond
32 Inzamam-Ul-Haq
31 Aravinda de Silva
30 Brett Lee
29 Sourav Ganguly
28 Michael Hussey
27 Allan Donald
26 Javed Miandad
25 Andrew Symonds
24 MS Dhoni
23 Curtly Ambrose
22 Zaheer Abbas
21 Saqlain Mushtaq
20 Richard Hadlee
19 Lance Klusener
18 Dean Jones
17 Imran Khan
16 Waqar Younis
15 Jacques Kallis
14 Shane Warne
13 Kapil Dev
12 Brian Lara
11 Sanath Jayasuriya
10 Ricky Ponting
9 Shaun Pollock
8 Muttiah Muralitharan
7 Joel Garner
6 Michael Bevan
5 Glenn McGrath
4 Adam Gilchrist
3 Wasim Akram
2 Sachin Tendulkar
1 Viv Richards



Players by nation
Australia 14
West Indies 9
Pakistan 8
South Africa 6
New Zealand 5
India 4
Sri Lanka 3
England 1

Current players vs. Past Players
10 vs. 40 (Bracken and Jayasuriya are considered past in my calculations).
 
Last edited:

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
since there are only two wicket keepers in the top 50 i could only put together two legitimate teams. so here are the first and second xis selected by CW.

tendulkar
gilchrist +
ponting
richards
lara
bevan
pollock
akram
murali
garner
mcgrath
AB de Villiers could be considered the 3rd keeper if you wanted to name another team.

I don't really have a problem with Lara making our top team ahead of Jayasuriya for team balance purposes. I agree that with your team it looks a lot more solid with Lara (or another middle order bat) in front of Sanath.
 

bagapath

International Captain
okay team three

ganguly
anwar
abbas
miandad
hussey
de villers (wk)
symonds
brett lee
saqlain
ambrose
donald
 

morgieb

Request Your Custom Title Now!
So in theory the first XI would be....

1. Gilchrist +
2. Jayasuriya
3. Ponting
4. Tendulkar
5. Richards
6. Bevan
7. Pollock
8. Akram
9. Garner
10. Murali
11. McGrath

Batting lineup a little short, but otherwise it's a gun first XI.
 

Francis

State Vice-Captain
If there's one bloke I can accept finishing ahead of Tendulkar and Akram it's King Viv. He'd have been third on my list, if I were to make a list.

I'm glad Akram was the highest ranked bowler. Really, really, he deserves it.
 

Francis

State Vice-Captain
How do you guys feel about top order batsmen and middle order batsmen with regard to stats?

I personally think it's easier for an ODI batsman to have a higher average if he plays in the middle order, where field restrictions are lifted, and singles are easy to take. Look at Michael Clarke's stats.
 

morgieb

Request Your Custom Title Now!
2nd XI would be....

Lara
Miandad
Dhoni +
Abbas
Jones
Kallis
Imran
Kapil
Klusener
Warne
Waqar

Dickload of all-rounders it seems.
 

smash84

The Tiger King
How do you guys feel about top order batsmen and middle order batsmen with regard to stats?

But the middle order batsmen usually don't get too much time in the middle either. They can boost their averages by not outs as well though......

I personally think it's easier for an ODI batsman to have a higher average if he plays in the middle order, where field restrictions are lifted, and singles are easy to take. Look at Michael Clarke's stats.
2nd XI would be....

Lara
Miandad
Dhoni +
Abbas
Jones
Kallis
Imran
Kapil
Klusener
Warne
Waqar

Dickload of all-rounders it seems.
lol....true......although there bowling is quite awesome too.
 

Top