Perhaps, but Raina looks like the kind of bloke that can score runs. Poor technique but has temperament. Besides, Amla would replace Khawaja in that case.Reckon Amla will be a safer bet than Raina right now.
I'd have a specialist keep rather than have AB do it personally.
I went with de Villiers as there is only Jayawardene worldwide who i rate as a gloveman but he is already 31 so might not be around for too long.The rest are all backstops who can bat or who can't in Ramdin's case.Perhaps, but Raina looks like the kind of bloke that can score runs. Poor technique but has temperament. Besides, Amla would replace Khawaja in that case.
Your second point is fair...but can't think of a keeper. Paine may not really get a fair crack as he isn't really bashing the door down, Dhoni's meh, Prior's meh, Kashual Silva or Dinesh Chandimal's still unproven, Haider quit Pakistan and Akmal's a hack, Ramdin's a hack and don't know if the WI's have better options, Hopkins isn't a long term option and I don't know who else would keep, and Taibu's a bit too...confrontational. Rahim maybe, but he doesn't look as talented as others.
Obviously however, SA might not even pick de Villiers as their keeper!
Yeah Amla's pretty good, just don't really know if he'll be that good though. Hard to say at this stage.Prior's not bad nowadays but age is a factor there. 28 is on the borderline where you could say that without being an exceptional 50+ bat you might not stick around to make a decade team.
I like the look of Paine though. Very good keeper - extremely agile, although Haddin has a better knack for taking speccys (like today) and looks a quality bat in tests. No idea why he doesn't do better in Shield though other than the obvious "throws away starts" - there's a reason for those things, usually.
As for Raina - I don't know. Amla's not bad temperamentally either, you know. And is obviously much less likely to be exposed overseas based on what I've seen of the two.
Well you can't say it for anyone. Yes Amla's good. I'll grant that. But there are many good players not on my list. We'll see who's the better player in 10 years time.But you can say it for Rania?
such a great description. respect.11) Ajantha Mendis (25)
I'm a firm believer in the principal that you will get wickets if the opposition has no idea what you are doing. Short of arbitrarily charging in astride a bear, there's not much Mendis can do to make his action more of a mystery. Has been good in Tests and outstanding in LO cricket.
WELLS zJosh Brodie
Bradley Cachopa+
Kane Williamson
Ross Taylor*
Jesse Ryder
Corey Anderson
Jono Boult/Sam Wells
Nick Beard
Tim Southee
Trent Boult
Hamish Bennett
Obviously.
Yes, I also found it highly implausible.WELLS z
Gambhir is as old as G SmithGambhir
Tamim
Khawaja
Williamson
Morgan
Matthews
Randiv
Steyn
Roach
Sreesanth
Chahar
Wells is a gun.Yes, I also found it highly implausible.
Fix'dHughes
Cooper
Khawaja
De Villiers
Ferguson
Smith
T Paine
Fast bowlers I guess
Mendis bowling a bear.
I picked a sub-continental player...not biased enough!Fix'd
Bit biased, don't you think?
Any XI without Jeets sucksJosh Brodie
Bradley Cachopa+
Kane Williamson
Ross Taylor*
Jesse Ryder
Corey Anderson
Jono Boult/Sam Wells
Nick Beard
Tim Southee
Trent Boult
Hamish Bennett
Obviously.