shiv vs lara vs ponting vs sachin ?

[sammy2]

If you had one vacant spot available to fill which of these players would you choose ?

 

[Uppercut]

Darren Sammy.

 

[boris_denominat]

darren bravo

 

[Pratters]

Dipak Patel ftw.

 

[sammy2]

Please people, vote with your heart.
Who would rather have playing for you.

 

[boris_denominat]

my heart, sire, goes for darren bravo, i cannot change it's torrid path.

 

[Pratters]

Darren Powell or Dwayne Bravo you mean.

 

[boris_denominat]

I said darren bravo

 

[Pratters]

Cricinfo - Players and Officials - Darren Bravo

Ah, cool.

 

[boris_denominat]

Cricinfo - Players and Officials - Darren Bravo

it is uncool that i cannnot post in caps lock stylee

 

[boris_denominat]

 

[Matt79]

lol at Shiv's inclusion. Great player and all but the other three are all time greats.

 

[sammy2]

Honestly, if you don't want to debate or you don't have any respect for me, atleast have respect for yourself and ignore the thread. I wouldn't be spamming anyone's thread.

 

[sammy2]

lol at Shiv's inclusion. Great player and all but the other three are all time greats.

Botham said chanderpaul is one of the greatest the world has ever seen.

 

[boris_denominat]

botham says! botham says graham napier is the new such and such, botham says 'id bowl first on this flat deck'

 

[sammy2]

I would take shiv in my test team for sure, and I would take him in alot of ODI situations aswell.

 

[ret]

considering their best forms, Lara in tests by hair's margin for his big 100s and Sachin in ODIs

 

[bagapath]

sachin, lara and ponting have strong cases for selection in either form of the game. voted for sachin in ODIs the only selection for an all-time XI beyond argument.

 

[Pratters]

sachin, lara and ponting have strong cases for selection in either form of the game. voted for sachin in ODIs the only selection for an all-time XI beyond argument.

Fair point.

 

[Uppercut]

sachin, lara and ponting have strong cases for selection in either form of the game. voted for sachin in ODIs the only selection for an all-time XI beyond argument.

Yeah, pretty good point that. Plenty of people would have all-time test XIs with no Ponting or Lara or Tendulkar and it's fair enough because when it gets to that stage of quality there's rarely much to choose between players. But i can't imagine there'd be many who would pick an all-time ODI XI without Sachin at the top of the order.