• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official India in New Zealand***

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Unfortunately, barring injury, Harby will play in the XI ahead of Mishy.
I know, it's a shame selectors are such a notoriously conservative bunch. Mishy's the better bet for success, but if Harbs gets picked and looks blunt (which happens often in non-SC matches) they'll get nowhere near the flak they'd get if Mishy got picked and looked blunt.
 

Precambrian

Banned
I know, it's a shame selectors are such a notoriously conservative bunch. Mishy's the better bet for success, but if Harbs gets picked and looks blunt (which happens often in non-SC matches) they'll get nowhere near the flak they'd get if Mishy got picked and looked blunt.
AWTA. But again, Mishy is a totally unknown quantity outside India. And for a series where we have struggled always, better to go with safe than sorry approach,
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
AWTA. But again, Mishy is a totally unknown quantity outside India. And for a series where we have struggled always, better to go with safe than sorry approach,
Not that being an unknown quantity is in any remote way a bad thing for a leg-spinner. Nor is picking the player who has already failed against New Zealand the "safe" approach. But yeah it's understandable thinking.
 

Maximus0723

State Regular
This should be the T20 XI:
  • Sehwag
  • Gambhir
  • Yuvraj
  • Dhoni
  • Raina
  • Rohit Sharma
  • Irfan (LMF)
  • Harbhajan (OB)
  • Praveen (RMF)
  • Zaheer (LFM)
  • Ishant (RFM)
The best pick. Mostly specialists. You have a very powerful top four that should be utilised fully, with a middle-order that can string partnerships, and strikers at seven, eight and nine. If there's a doubt about Irfan (hopefully not, this is a T20) they can pick Ojha or Mishra.
uhh...where is Yusuf?
 

Precambrian

Banned
Mishra dominated Australia on Test Deubt. Was something.
On assisting tracks tbh. But still an achievement. UC's love for Mishy is like the love some CWers have for O Brien, Jeetan, Watson etc. It just cannot be explained why, it's like falling in love. It's blind.
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
What's with the Mishra love? He's a decent prospect, nothing more.
Nah, he's awesome. He's very accurate, gives the ball a massive rip, bowls subtle googlies and top-spinners, can both flight the ball and push it through and does well under pressure. And he was more responsible than anyone (bar, perhaps, Dhoni) for the stuffing of Australia. What's not to love?

Actually, really I just think he's ridiculously adorable. I can see why you'd not want to get excited with the history of Indian bowlers making great starts then badly falling away. But yeah, Mishy rules.
 

cowboysfan

U19 Debutant
This should be the T20 XI:
  • Sehwag
  • Gambhir
  • Yuvraj
  • Dhoni
  • Raina
  • Rohit Sharma
  • Irfan (LMF)
  • Harbhajan (OB)
  • Praveen (RMF)
  • Zaheer (LFM)
  • Ishant (RFM)
The best pick. Mostly specialists. You have a very powerful top four that should be utilised fully, with a middle-order that can string partnerships, and strikers at seven, eight and nine. If there's a doubt about Irfan (hopefully not, this is a T20) they can pick Ojha or Mishra.
rohit in and yusuf out.lol
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
On assisting tracks tbh. But still an achievement. UC's love for Mishy is like the love some CWers have for O Brien, Jeetan, Watson etc. It just cannot be explained why, it's like falling in love. It's blind.
Hardly an assisting track, really, he just turned the ball on it. Leg-spinners do that on most tracks. I don't think I've ever seen you undersell an Indian performance before, what's going on? :p
 

Precambrian

Banned
Hardly an assisting track, really, he just turned the ball on it. Leg-spinners do that on most tracks. I don't think I've ever seen you undersell an Indian performance before, what's going on? :p
PR pressures. See OT. :p

Nah, other than that, Mohali indeed was a reasonably good surface to bowl spin in. And yes, the novelty factor, seeing a genuinely gifted wristie looping it out gently and yet getting ripping turn confounded the Aussies. It should not be forgotten that in the next two matches, Mishy was reasonably well dealt with by the same opposition. Also, he was lukewarm at the best against England, who imho have the worst players of wrist spin perhaps.
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
PR pressures. See OT. :p

Nah, other than that, Mohali indeed was a reasonably good surface to bowl spin in. And yes, the novelty factor, seeing a genuinely gifted wristie looping it out gently and yet getting ripping turn confounded the Aussies. It should not be forgotten that in the next two matches, Mishy was reasonably well dealt with by the same opposition. Also, he was lukewarm at the best against England, who imho have the worst players of wrist spin perhaps.
Ehm, well in fairness, he suffered at the hands of players he should have already had. Ishant Sharma dropped a dolly off Michael Clarke (who went on to hit a century) in the third test off his bowling, and MS Dhoni's poor positioning to spinners gave Andrew Strauss a second innings century against England. Collingwood edged him through the slip fielder's legs too on his way to a century. In both series, at times he bowled badly, and at times he bowled well without reward. Other times he chipped in with the odd one here and there. The debut innings was the only time when everything really came together, but he still came out of his first five tests with an average of 29, so it's not like he didn't do anything else. Especially when you consider the bashing pretty much every other bowler got during those two series.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
So who does everyone think will open with McIntosh in the Tests?

I suppose Guptill has the inside running if he does well in the ODIs, but his First Class record is pretty damn poor. That said, he did score a big hundred in his only Championship outing this season IIRC and he's only 22 so I dare say it'll be him.
 

adharcric

International Coach
This should be the T20 XI:
  • Sehwag
  • Gambhir
  • Yuvraj
  • Dhoni
  • Raina
  • Rohit Sharma
  • Irfan (LMF)
  • Harbhajan (OB)
  • Praveen (RMF)
  • Zaheer (LFM)
  • Ishant (RFM)
The best pick. Mostly specialists. You have a very powerful top four that should be utilised fully, with a middle-order that can string partnerships, and strikers at seven, eight and nine. If there's a doubt about Irfan (hopefully not, this is a T20) they can pick Ojha or Mishra.
Yusuf Pathan is a better T20 batsman than Rohit Sharma, anywhere in the order.
 

Top