• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official Australia in India***

Precambrian

Banned
Awesome, Awesome, Awesome gesture from Dhoni in getting Kumble also to share the trophy.

Pissed of at Krejza getting MoM. For me, he's been mediocre at best.

Glad Ishy got MoS.
 

GotSpin

Hall of Fame Member
Was it? 8 wickets, 12 wickets and 10 wickets fell on the last three days. It's not negative if it yields a result.

MoTS Sharma. Definitely deserves it more than Gambhir.

India win, and two bowlers are MoTM and MoTS. I'm in heaven.
10-11 overs per hour. Negative bowling tactics. Great stuff isn't it.
 

Precambrian

Banned
Without having sour grapes, I'd have to say that you would have thought it unlikely that Dhoni would manage to do something nearly as bad as Ponting did yesterday, but the period where Sehwag and Bhajji were bowl wides to Hayden and Hussey with the field all back on the fence was mind-bogglingly poor and was in many ways as unedifying a spectacle as Ponting's efforts yesterday. At least Ponting had the small fig-leaf of attempting to stay within the laws regarding over-rates - Dhoni was just being defensive (which in itself is fair enough) but doing it in an obviously counter-productive manner. The last couple of days have been a terrible advertisement for Test cricket.
A big booo, he won the test match, didnt he?
 

irfan

State Captain
Was it? 8 wickets, 12 wickets and 10 wickets fell on the last three days. It's not negative if it yields a result.

MoTS Sharma. Definitely deserves it more than Gambhir.

India win, and two bowlers are MoTM and MoTS. I'm in heaven.
You would be if you got up there by a space elevator.
 

Johnners

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Was it? 8 wickets, 12 wickets and 10 wickets fell on the last three days. It's not negative if it yields a result.

MoTS Sharma. Definitely deserves it more than Gambhir.

India win, and two bowlers are MoTM and MoTS. I'm in heaven.
Disagree with that so much.
 

GotSpin

Hall of Fame Member
Oh the over rates - yea absolutely. I was referring to the field placings and bowling. If the bowling builds pressure and takes wickets - I call that smart cricket. Not negative.
There was no pressure when Dhoni had every single fielder on the boundary, bar two inside the circle, with Sehwag/Bhaji bowling either way outside out the off stump, or down the leg. Full credit to Mishra though
 

Johnners

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Oh the over rates - yea absolutely. I was referring to the field placings and bowling. If the bowling builds pressure and takes wickets - I call that smart cricket. Not negative.
The tactics at various stages yesterday and today were not about building pressure and taking wickets though.
 

vic_orthdox

Global Moderator
Was it? 8 wickets, 12 wickets and 10 wickets fell on the last three days. It's not negative if it yields a result.
MoTS Sharma. Definitely deserves it more than Gambhir.

India win, and two bowlers are MoTM and MoTS. I'm in heaven.
I'd like to introduce you to my friend, Mr Katich.
 

silentstriker

The Wheel is Forever
Disagree with that so much.
Well I guess we'll disagree. I don't necessarily think boundaries are exciting. I want a game that eventually leads to a result. If a particular tactic is effective in doing that, it's a good one.

Australia won the series in 2004 by consistently setting defensive fields and choking off the boundaries. That was good strategy, it wasn't negative. It wasn't 8-1 with bowling wide, but it wasn't like that went on for the whole, or even most, of the day. It's another tool to be used at the right time, which he did, and got wickets. In the end, that's the goal. It's not as cool as seeing five men in the slips, but I don't think that's the only way to play good cricket.
 

pup11

International Coach
Well done India - well deserved series win. Were the better team pretty much throughout. Australia handicapped themselves with bizarre selection decisions, and showed some uncharacteristic lapses in application. We also stopped doing the little things well.

For India its now ahead of them to show that they can reproduce this level consistently and against all opponents. They match up, and play well, against Australia, not having lost to them in 6 encounters. If Australia continues to beat all other teams, then it will remain on India to win a series in Australia before the #1 mantle is considered to have been passed, but they are definitely now the team that has emerged that can beat Australia consistently.

For the Aussies, hall of mirrors time boys. Ponting's lack of acumen when required to think on his feet showed this series, most noticeably in slowing our over rate to a crawl as he over-fretted, -worried, and fiddled with his bowlers and their field. Our lack of a specialist spinner was exposed horribly in the first three tests, and White's inclusion in the team defied logic. Our pace attack was poor, with Clark and Lee suddenly looking their age. Haddin had a poor series, and will need to produce against NZ or the selectors might be tempted to experiment with Ronchi. On the positive side, Krejza made a good debut, Katich was fair-to-good in the role of opener again - enough, with the Windies tour to suggest that he could fill the role for a few years, and Watson finally got an decent run in the team and while not setting the world on fire statistically, didn't look out of place as an allrounder in the team, although I'd like to see him produce more with the bat.

Without having sour grapes, I'd have to say that you would have thought it unlikely that Dhoni would manage to do something nearly as bad as Ponting did yesterday, but the period where Sehwag and Bhajji were bowl wides to Hayden and Hussey with the field all back on the fence was mind-bogglingly poor and was in many ways as unedifying a spectacle as Ponting's efforts yesterday. At least Ponting had the small fig-leaf of attempting to stay within the laws regarding over-rates - Dhoni was just being defensive (which in itself is fair enough) but doing it in an obviously counter-productive manner. The last couple of days have been a terrible advertisement for Test cricket.

In a way, I'm relieved that Australia and India will now have something of a break from one another - and it has nothing to do with not likely losing (I loved the 05 Ashes). The Border-Gavaskar Trophy should be the showcase of world cricket, but as teams, the heights that they produce against each other have been, in the last few encounters, outweighed by the number of issues that are bad for cricket and quite unpleasant. There's blame on both sides, but more than anything, I think a bit of a period without clashing with the same personalities over and over again. Just my opinion.

Making wholesale changes would be a lame thing to do, with the kind of team that was picked for this tour, the lack of experience in the bowling line-up and the conditions that they were pitted up against this was very likely to happen, and eventually as feared before the start of he series, all these things in the end proved to be major factors in Australia performing as badly as they did, the Aussie fast-bowlers bowled the wrong lengths on these pitches and paid heavily for it and the lack of any spinner in the first three games also clearly hurt us, the batting was good through the series except for Mohali and that pretty much cost Australia the series and this game too, so frankly speaking not many positives for Australia to take out of this series, except for Watto fitness and improvement in bowling and maybe even Katich' performance as an opener to some extent, but i do expect them to bounce back strongly and do well at home this summer, but it would be while playing away from home where they would be truly tested from now on.
 

Top