• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official Australia in India***

vic_orthdox

Global Moderator
This series may be fantastic for Johnson. With the side looking to bowl straight, he'll hit the deck hard, and make them work for runs, rather than trying to swing the ball back through the gate like he has been; he doesn't have to be Wasim.
 

masterblaster

International Captain
Very surprising, yet pleasing to see Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli step up against a pretty decent Australian bowling lineup. Certainly have done their chances of a test call up a world of good once the big guns retire. I'm glad Yuvraj Singh failed, he's a liability as far as test matches are concerned.
 

pup11

International Coach
Very surprising, yet pleasing to see Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli step up against a pretty decent Australian bowling lineup. Certainly have done their chances of a test call up a world of good once the big guns retire. I'm glad Yuvraj Singh failed, he's a liability as far as test matches are concerned.
Both of them certainly owe Krezja a few drinks imo.:ph34r:
 

Precambrian

Banned
Both of them certainly owe Krezja a few drinks imo.:ph34r:
Yes. However they were also up to the task even against other bowlers too. Johnson benefited hugely from bad strokes played, and Lee's only wicket was fortuitous. And Clark was handled pretty well. So good performance overall by Indians.
 

social

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Yes. However they were also up to the task even against other bowlers too. Johnson benefited hugely from bad strokes played, and Lee's only wicket was fortuitous. And Clark was handled pretty well. So good performance overall by Indians.
They both played well

However, it was an incredibly slow wicket and they still looked ropey at times against the short ball
 

Top_Cat

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Not seeing why Johnson has to be able to swing the ball to be effective anywhere, let alone India. Glenn McGrath has a great record in India and he barely swung a ball. Johnson has never been much of a swing bowler, any success he's had has been when he just tried to bowl quick, aggressive lines and lengths with the odd bit of movement away. Certainly he should be adding to his armory as time goes by but his stock ball has always been about hitting the seam and trying to change this diminishes his wicket-taking ability by heaps.

As Jack said, it could be the ideal scenario for him this series with the lines the Aussies are looking to bowl. But not if he tries to swing it. Personally, if the field is set to suffocate scoring (as the Aussies appear to be trying again), Johnson sticks to trying to hit the seam and there's a bit of uneven bounce, that would be bloody tough to score off and damn tough to face in general. Can see a few stumps going bye-byes.
 
Last edited:

social

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Not seeing why Johnson has to be able to swing the ball to be effective anywhere, let alone India. Glenn McGrath has a great record in India and he barely swung a ball. Johnson has never been much of a swing bowler, any success he's had has been when he just tried to bowl quick, aggressive lines and lengths with the odd bit of movement away. Certainly he should be adding to his armory as time goes by but his stock ball has always been about hitting the seam and trying to change this diminishes his wicket-taking ability by heaps.

As Jack said, it could be the ideal scenario for him this series with the lines the Aussies are looking to bowl. But not if he tries to swing it. Personally, if the field is set to suffocate scoring (as the Aussies appear to be trying again), Johnson sticks to trying to hit the seam and there's a bit of uneven bounce, that would be bloody tough to score off and damn tough to face in general. Can see a few stumps going bye-byes.
Yep

His strength is pace, bounce, odd bit of seam and stamina

He is not a swing bowler and shouldnt try to be
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Highlights-

The batting of the top four was forgettable. Jaffer and Chopra were getting starts and then threw their wickets away. Badrinath was done in by a bad decision, and his early dismissal was a shocker, especially since he's the one most likely to make a Test debut. It's good to see Kohli and Rohit Sharma pile on centuries in quick time, as this is a team against which a good performance counts, even if it's not a Test match.

Both looked supreme against the spinners. They used their feet well, made full use of the token boundary ball that was coming and made full use of that free-scoring opportunity that came along. They didn't face the seamers too much, and eventually, the seamers got them out on a very slow pitch. Sharma looked more stable out there, while Kohli was quite impulsive and took more than a few risks. The running between wickets was also very neat, as also pinching gaps in the outfield.

The Australian seamers were fast and too hot to handle. Bowling in the 140's regularly, Lee, Johnson and Siddle made batting very uncomfortable for the Indian reserves. This is a taste of what's to come for the Indian frontline batting, and given their weaknesses against pace, they won't score too much, especially in the initial overs. Clark got a wicket and didn't bowl as fast, but kept things steady. Johnson struggled a little with his line, but at his pace, even bad balls looked like taking wickets. He didn't try to swing the ball, but kept it down that channel and was rewarded with three wickets.

In comparison, the Australians have major problems with their spinners. Jason Krejza bowled utter rubbish, offering a boundary-ball every over, and even got his foot down too far at times. Even as there is talk of the Indians not playing spin as good as they used to, they can surely smash what comes from him easily all around the park. In fact, it makes sense not to include him in the playing XI and go in with an all-pace attack, as that will give the Indians little breathing space.
 

silentstriker

The Wheel is Forever
It's no surprise, its the cycles of any sport.

Before Warne the last really top spinner Australia had was Benaud. There were others in between who did a serviceable job, but they weren't that flash.

A lot of the spinners we have haven't played that much FC cricket - Warne's FC record before he played for Australia wasn't great (not as bad as these blokes, granted). Had to give one of them a go on the subcontinent.
No you did not. It's a ridiculous notion that you should play a sub-par bowler just because he is a spinner. Why would you want to let all the pressure go every time he comes on to bowl? YOu have a bunch of part time spinners in the squad, and I have no clue how people can think they'll do worse than this guy (or any other guy).

I wish Jason had taken 5/60 or something, to get him in the squad.

Although it's an incredibly slow wicket, it's a good workout for the bowlers

Thought Johnson and Siddle were the pick whilst Lee has looked ok despite getting no assistance whatsoever

Indian commentators appraisal of Krezja

"Off spinners are generally treated with disdain in the subcontinent and unless he improves a lot, he'll be no different."

TBH, I dont know where this theory about fingerspinners being an attacking option in India came from - from what I've seen over the years, that's nothing more than a crock dreamt up by some PR hack to put a positive light on Krezja's selection
AWTA
 

ret

International Debutant
nice performances by Rohit and Kohali .... too bad this wasn't a test match or they probably would have been the first Indian pair to hit 100s on debut :devil2:
 

ret

International Debutant
if some of the guys from the BP11 were to be mixed with Sehwag, Gambhir, Tendulkar, Dhoni, Zak, Ishant and probably Bhajji then that would be a more than useful team and probably be all over the OZ team

come B'lore, the likes of Dravid, Laxman, Ganguly and Kumble may make OZ team competitive. and they are likely to drop a few catches too with probably little chance to take the sharp ones
 

Uppercut

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Indian commentators appraisal of Krezja

"Off spinners are generally treated with disdain in the subcontinent and unless he improves a lot, he'll be no different."

TBH, I dont know where this theory about fingerspinners being an attacking option in India came from - from what I've seen over the years, that's nothing more than a crock dreamt up by some PR hack to put a positive light on Krezja's selection
Thank you social, been labouring to make this point for weeks :p
 

Jakester1288

International Regular
Hopefully BP go on to post a total in excess of 450 tomorrow, and put Australians under pressure. Can't wait to see how Ponting plays Ojha and Chawla.
I'm definitely looking forward to it, hoping he can get some good match practice in against some decent spinners on some spinning tracks. I have never seen Ojha, so I cannot comment on him, but I have seen Chawla, and he is nothing like Harbhajan and Kumble. He is smaller, and doesn't generate as much bounce as Kumble. He is a leg spinner, so Ponting would not be getting any practice for when he plays Singh later in the series. Unless Ojha is an off-spinner, Ponting is not looking all that good at the moment.
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Yep

His strength is pace, bounce, odd bit of seam and stamina

He is not a swing bowler and shouldnt try to be
AWTA - they tried to make McGrath a swing bowler in his early years - thank God he stopped listening.
 

Top