Irrelevant sixth option.BTW why is Paul Adams in the poll? I can think of several players who should be there instead.
Paul Adams isn't bad enough to be an irrelevant option. Well to me it wasn't obvious enough I guessIrrelevant sixth option.
Anyway, Kallis. No question here.
I don't see the point in excluding him when we are judging, I assume, purely on cricketing ability and success on the field.Hansie Cronje is not counted due to his least then reputable activities outside of cricket
True, but on that basis he wouldn't be included either.I don't see the point in excluding him when we are judging, I assume, purely on cricketing ability and success on the field.
Paul Adams should be nowhere near that poll.
Paul Adams is the irrelevant final option, no different had I put 'Coca-cola' or Bryan Habana's name down, even though he plays rugby. It is a CW traditionPaul Adams should be nowhere near that poll. If we had to choose a post-isolation XI, Adams wouldn't make the second side.
Cullinan wasn't the best, but I think was under-rated. If only he'd played in a different era from Warne He would have been remembered as one of the best batsmen that SA has ever produced.