Trueman and Bailey cover a very large number of fast-medium to fast bowlers including :
- Larwood, Voce, Bowes, Bedser, Les Jackson Tyson. Trueman himself, Statham, Snow, Willis and Botham from England
- Lindwall, Miller, Davidson. Mckenzie, Lillee, Thomson and Walker from Australia
- Adcock, Heine, Peter Pollock from South Africa
- Constatntine, Martindale, Hall, Griffith, Roberts, Holding, Garner and Croft from West Indies
- Fazal, Imran, Sarfraz and kapil from the sub-continent
- Cowie, Taylor and Hadlee from New Zealand
To put in excerpts about all would surely contravene copyright regulations. I will therefore put in my comments on what appears to be their views on how the leading ones in these match up in an all time greats line up which is what we are discussing.
1. Lindwall :
There is absolutely no doubt that both Trueman and Bailey consider Lindwall as the greatest fast bowler they have ever seen.
In the art of fast bowling Ray Lindwall has no peer. To me he was the greatest of them all. .... he made the ball leave the right hand batsman, the sure hallmark of a great, ... combined with the one that came back sharply off the seam ... later he learn(t) to bowl a very effective in-swinger.... born out of necessity....in the Lancashire league..
There he .... was regularly beating the outside edge with pace and swerve ...also... there was a tendency for the slips to put down the catch if the batsman did get an edge.
It quickly dawned on Ray....an in-swinger was the obvious answer. Ray went into the nets...the effort worthwhile because, unlike so many outswing bowlers who did this and end up with an inner which went early..... Ray produced an iner which dipped in fast, late and went a long way.
Ray had the most rhythmical accelrating run up I have ever seen..he was so beautifully balanced as he went in to the delivery stride .... I have always thought that if Beethoven had loved cricket and seen Lindwall bowl, he would have written another symphony.
In addition to his pace and action, Ray had three other essential attributes. Firstly, he was a fine, natural athlete... Secondly, ... he had a killer instinct which enabled him to produce that extra venom when it was most needed...and finally, he had the stamina and the heart that enabled him to come back at the end of a long hot day
I do not believe I shall see the likes of Ray Lindwall again..
2. Lillee :
Both of them also seem to rate Lillee behind Limdwall as the second best.
Lilee is ... unquestionably one of the all time great quick bowlers of the game... he is the last of what I would describe as the classical fast bowlers.....
He is fast bowling perfection.... a fine running action worthy of an Olympic athlete.... couple(d) with balance, rhythm, fire in the belly, stamina and a big heart and you are close to greatness. The last piece of the jig-saw is the bowling action which in the case of Lillee is superb. His action and timing can not be bettered.
Instead of pumping his arms down his sides, he held them quite high in front of the lower portion of his chest and thus achieved the smoothness which he believes has greatly helped him in the twilight of his career. I am sure he is right....his approach... which he starts slowly before accelrating into full speed, to be even better balanced when he reaches his delivery stride and to be high when he releases the ball.
I would strongly advise any budding quick bowler with a good physique to get hold of a video of Dennis bowling and study it carefully, for here is a wonderful example of the classical action. His left arm reaches for the sky and points towards fine-leg so that he is sideways -on to the batsman and looking round the side of his left arm. Then the right arm comes over the top, swings across close to the body and finishes outside his left leg. Finally there is that sweet controlled follow through which reduces the strain on his body.
In terms of figures, Lillee is the greatest fast bowler ever, but I believe that Ray Lindwall was even better and despite a lower arm action, he swung the ball even more. It would have been marvellous to have seen the two 'L's' in action together.
There can be few more exhilarating sights in cricket than watching bowlers like Lindwall, Hall and Lillee in action against top-class batsmen, a combination of excitement and beauty, poetry in motion.
The true greatness of Dennis Lillee is reflected in the fact that, when increasin years had taken some of his fire, he remained an outstanding wicket taker at the international level This was becasue he had other weapons in addition to speed; the away-swinger, a 'nip-backer', change of pace and of course superb control.
Such skills take years of application and practice, the right temperament and technique to perfect, and without such groundwork most bowlers will never rise above the ordinary.
Dennis is a complete fast bowler, a thinking cricketer who has gone on harvesting wickets long after he lost his fearsome pace. He is the Muhammed Ali of the cricket field, an artist while Thomson is essentially a slugger with a knock out punch but no subtlety.
3. Wes Hall :
Hall is rated as the greatest of the fast bowlers to come from the West Indies.
Wes Hall ... was to me, easily the finest fast bowler the West Indies have ever produced. He stood over six feet tall and was so magnificiently proportioned that he could have been designed by a precision engineer.
In addition to pace through the air, he had a classical fast bowler's action with his left shoulder coming right round so that it pointed down the wicket at the batsman. This enabled him to move the ball away from the right-hander and, combined with his speed, was one of the main reasons why he was the West Indies' main wicket taker...
The Wes Hall run-up was the longest I have seen, but umlike the marathon excursions of subsequent imitators, it was one of the most graceful it has been my pleasure to witness. He reminded me of a train leaving the station: that slow deliberate start gradually building up to full speed as he approached his delivery stride. This incorporated the timing, balance and rhythm required to propel the ball at a pace sufficient to alarm even the brave.
Wes Hall was built along the lines of the thoroughbred horses he loved so much and used to ride as a kid, a magnificent black stallion, lean, lithe and exciting to watch just moving towards the starting gates. Tall, graceful, broad-shouldered and narrow-hipped, Wes simply glided over the ground during his long, spectacular run-up from a mark near the edge of the boundary. Nobody ever complained about the length of his approach because it was one of the most beautiful sights in the game.
Wes seemed to flow into a high classical action and a glorious follow through. The outcome was exceptional speed, a natural away swing, lift from just short of a length and the occasional break-back.
His pace was never less than very fast and on occasions pure black lightening. Unquestionably he was amongst the quickest and most magnificent fast bowlers cricket has ever seen.
4. Andy Roberts :
He is rated (so it appears) to be the second best from the carribean after Wes Hall.
Roberts is able to bowl a very effective late out-swinger, as well as the ball which nips back sharply off the seam. His succes comes from speed combined with excellent control and the ability to change his pace without changing his action. He is a complete fast bowler.
In addition to a well disguised slower ball, Roberts possesses two bouncers which can not be picked before the ball is released.
Roberts is a thoughtful quickie who is eager to capitalise on the weakness of the batsman. He is helped by a balanced run-up which takes little effort out of him and allows him to camouflage his changes of pace, which is largely derived from powerful shoulders, arms and back. What has pleased me about his bowling is that if the batsman fails to make contact, there is evcery chance that the ball will hit the stumps. Furthermore, he controls himself much better than any of his contemporaries. His anger smoulders, rather than burst into flame.
5. Frank Tyson :
Both are unhesitating in calling him the fastest bowler they have seen or played with and against. But with nothing much to fall back upon once his pace was reduced.
I always say without fear of contradiction that the quickest bowler I have ever seen, or played against, was Frank Tyson.
Frank was so quick that I often saw him beat a batsman when his bat was still going up on the backlift !...Even on the Northants wicket, the distance between Frank at the commencement of his run and wicket-keeper Keith Andrews was 78 yards!. On a small ground the slips were close to the boundary.
...once his terrific pace was gone he had nothing to fall back upon. He relied so much on sheer strength that he did not posses the basic action, body swing and rhythm to last as long as, say, Dennis Lillee. Without the breath taking pace, he became just another bowler.
Frank Tyson was the fastest bowler England has produced since the war....Frank depended on sheer speed. He blew into county and Test cricket rather like the typhoon to which he was often likened, leaving behind him a trail of destruction before swiftly disappearing from the scene.
For a few short years, he was the quickest I ever played with or against. Holding and Lillee at their peak may have rivalled him for speed, and certainly were more complete bowlers, but I doubt if they were as fast through the air.
6. Mike Holding :
His famous 14 wicket spell against England is considered by Trueman as easily the greatest piece of fast bowling he has ever witnessed in his entire life.
I maintain that one of the greatest, possibly 'the greatest', piece of sustained fast bowling it has ever been my privilege to witness was by Michael Holding in the 1976 Test at The Oval. To appreciate the full significance of that performance it first necessary to realise that it was achieved on an absolute featherbed... It is fascinating and revealing to examine the figures of other fast and medium fast bowlers in that match.
Its interesting to see that like Lillee, they both rate Hall and then Roberts so high.
And like Imran they rate Lillee as the finest of the fast bowlers since 1970.
Alec Bedser :
Amongst fast medium bowlers, from those they saw, they rate Bedser, head and shoulders above all others. Even rating him slightly above Tate and slightly below Barnes (both of whom they did not see). Again these are not very different from the ratings of others, most famously Don Bradman who saw at least two of them