• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Shivnarine Chanderpaul

Ikki

Hall of Fame Member
AWTA also. There is no grounds to demean 12 runs average superiority. Not even these pitches. Averages now may be inflated a little, but not by that much. In fact, the difference between averages of batsmen 1-6 from now and the previous two decades is about 2-2.5 runs on average.
 

roseboy64

Cricket Web Content Updater
Barath is definitely not ahead of Smith. Barath has played 2 domestic seasons. He did very well in one and okay in the other. Devon Smith has been, relatively, piling on runs for several seasons now and overall is more prepared for Test cricket. I'm a Devon Smith fan, but his shot selection in Tests frustrates me no end. I'm a bigger Barath fan and I'd hate to see him ruined by being picked anytime soon.

Regarding Xavier Marshall, we can't read too much into one half century. In the past (on occasion) Devon Smith has looked as good as Marshall did in that innings. And that's with an impressive domestic record under his belt, which is something Marshall can't claim to have. Marshall isn't suddenly better than Smith because of one innings. Chattergoon looks the stuff though.

And regarding Morton, I really hope he's dropped after this Test. The man is utterly useless at Test level. As if his indiscipline in the first Test wasn't bad enough, the shot he played on day two of this one was unforgivable.
Made no mention of anyone being better. Just disappointed at thier efforts so afr and want to see new blood.
 

FaaipDeOiad

Hall of Fame Member
This guy is just so, so good at the moment. A truly amazing patch of form, comparable to Yousuf from a couple of seasons ago.

Always been a batsman I've enjoyed, but he's taken it to another level.
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
When I think of the fine player Shivnarine Chanderpaul has developed into, I wonder, did anyone here see it coming? If so, what was it about his batting that clued you in?
I remember when I was around ten years old. I was very small for my age, skinny and not strong by any standards.

I had not learnt anything about how to bat but I had the only bat in the neighborhood so I got to play with the big boys.

I had no clue as to how to bat. So finally after struggling for a long time, I developed a technique of my own. I stood awkwardly and, I am sure uglier than hell, at the crease, watched the ball from the bowlers hand like a hawk, I watched it off the wicket and then as it came close to me I put my bat in its way and turned it a bit (often it turned on its own) one way or the other, edging (smartly) on either side of the wicket.

The big bad fast bowlers got very agitated and came in bowling faster and that just helped my edges to go for boundaries instead of singles or scampered twos.

Of course, I joined a proper club at 14, got good coaching and started playing in front of the wicket.

Chanderpaul, with all his impressive Test records, has always reminded me of myself as a ten year old :)
 
Last edited:

Jakester1288

International Regular
I remember when I was around ten years old. I was very small for my age, skinny and not strong by any standards.

I had not learnt anything about how to bat but I had the only bat in the neighborhood so I got to play with the big boys.

I had no clue as to how to bat. So finally after struggling for a long time, I developed a technique of my own. I stood awkwardly and, I am sure uglier than hell, at the crease, watched the ball from the bowlers hand like a hawk, I watched it off the wicket and then as it came close to me I put my bat in its way and turned it a bit (often it turned on its own) one way or the other, edging (smartly) on either side of the wicket.

The big bad fast bowlers got very agitated and came in bowling faster and that just helped my edges to go for boundaries instead of singles or scampered twos.

Of course, I joined a proper club at 14, got god coaching and started playing in front of the wicket.

Chanderpaul, with all his impressive Test records, has always reminded me of myself as a ten year old :)
God coached you? :ph34r:


:laugh:
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
God coached you? :ph34r:


:laugh:
Only God could have corrected SJS' technique.:laugh:
You are dead right.

My coach made lot of fun of how I was when I first came for coaching. It seems that after he had made me stand with the proper grip and the proper stance at the wicket, as he went back two thirds of the length of the wicket back, to throw balls at me to play, he found that my face was turned towards covers, due to the sideways stance which wan't yet natural to me.

So he asked me to turn my head and look towards him. According to him, every time he asked me to do that, I would just screw my face and towards him and look at him from the corner of my eyes with my head firmly turned towards covers :)

He always had a heartily laugh when he narrated it and I always felt it wasn't funny at all and that he repeated this story far too often :)
 

Jakester1288

International Regular
You are dead right.

My coach made lot of fun of how I was when I first came for coaching. It seems that after he had made me stand with the proper grip and the proper stance at the wicket, as he went back two thirds of the length of the wicket back, to throw balls at me to play, he found that my face was turned towards covers, due to the sideways stance which wan't yet natural to me.

So he asked me to turn my head and look towards him. According to him, every time he asked me to do that, I would just screw my face and towards him and look at him from the corner of my eyes with my head firmly turned towards covers :)

He always had a heartily laugh when he narrated it and I always felt it wasn't funny at all and that he repeated this story far too often :)
:laugh:
 

Richard

Cricket Web Staff Member
This guy is just so, so good at the moment. A truly amazing patch of form, comparable to Yousuf from a couple of seasons ago.
Far better for my money. Yousuf's output of Dec05-Nov06 would've been halved, probably more, had everything that should've been out been out. Chanderpaul's would only have decreased slightly.
 

Richard

Cricket Web Staff Member
I'll show you some figures sometime when I'm not watching a Test, too.

I've said it before, but the scorebook is not everything when considering how well a batsman has batted.
 

Top