• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Should we ask Warne to come out of retirement?

Get Warney back!!


  • Total voters
    39

FRAZ

International Captain
Given the injury to MacGill? I know he'll be rusty, but a 60% ready-to-go Warne is probably a better bet than any of the spin alternatives.

Him leading us to a 4-0 series over India could be the perfect coda to his fairytale career! ;)
DOes it all has to do some thing with Murali's recent record ?
hehe
 

sideshowtim

Banned
DOes it all has to do some thing with Murali's recent record ?
hehe
Lol. Imagine if Murali retired just after this Test series against England and then Warne came out of retirement for the series against India and claimed it again.
 

howardj

International Coach
As a general rule, I don't like comebacks.

Once a man makes the hardest decision of his career, he should never (and never be asked) to go back.
 

MattO

Cricket Spectator
We're not that desperate...

I don't know why playing 4 quicks is seen as a cricketing sin. If the 4 best bowlers in the country are quicks, why on Earth shouldn't we play them?
Two seasons ago before Tait, Clark and Johnson emerged as viable options and Kaspa seemingly on the outer Australia's four best bowlers were McGrath, Warne, MacGill and Lee and they played five of the seven home Tests that summer. Kaspa was eventually recalled for the RSA series and Clark played where he emerged as a bowler who would soon later be described by Warne as the Worlds Best.

Even with McGrath gone our pace bowling stocks are looking good with someone like Bollinger IMO ranked at No.8 after Clark, Lee, Tait, Johnson, Noffke, Hilfenhaus, Gillespie and after Bollinger be Kaspa and McGoffin to round off the top 10.

Our spinning ranks after MacGill and Hogg as EWS would say is Dire. Maybe Watto should become a spinner.
 

sideshowtim

Banned
Two seasons ago before Tait, Clark and Johnson emerged as viable options and Kaspa seemingly on the outer Australia's four best bowlers were McGrath, Warne, MacGill and Lee and they played five of the seven home Tests that summer. Kaspa was eventually recalled for the RSA series and Clark played where he emerged as a bowler who would soon later be described by Warne as the Worlds Best.

Even with McGrath gone our pace bowling stocks are looking good with someone like Bollinger IMO ranked at No.8 after Clark, Lee, Tait, Johnson, Noffke, Hilfenhaus, Gillespie and after Bollinger be Kaspa and McGoffin to round off the top 10.

Our spinning ranks after MacGill and Hogg as EWS would say is Dire. Maybe Watto should become a spinner.
Bollinger doing very well this season indeed. Has come a long way. He has 34 wickets at 14 which is just magnificent.
 

MattO

Cricket Spectator
Bollinger doing very well this season indeed. Has come a long way. He has 34 wickets at 14 which is just magnificent.
Exactly. We have plenty of quick options and Bollinger wouldn't look out of place. Clark, Lee and Tait deserve top three billing IMO, but Johnson has done well, Noffke is in great form with the ball (batting a bonus), Hilfenhaus took 60 wickets last year, Gillespie is still bowling well, Magoffin is in great form and Kaspa looks like getting back to fitness.
 

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
Two seasons ago before Tait, Clark and Johnson emerged as viable options and Kaspa seemingly on the outer Australia's four best bowlers were McGrath, Warne, MacGill and Lee and they played five of the seven home Tests that summer. Kaspa was eventually recalled for the RSA series and Clark played where he emerged as a bowler who would soon later be described by Warne as the Worlds Best.

Even with McGrath gone our pace bowling stocks are looking good with someone like Bollinger IMO ranked at No.8 after Clark, Lee, Tait, Johnson, Noffke, Hilfenhaus, Gillespie and after Bollinger be Kaspa and McGoffin to round off the top 10.

Our spinning ranks after MacGill and Hogg as EWS would say is Dire. Maybe Watto should become a spinner.
You serious? Surely one of the Vic quicks would now be ahead of Kaspa!
 

MattO

Cricket Spectator
You serious? Surely one of the Vic quicks would now be ahead of Kaspa!
Benefit of the doubt to a fine Australian bowler who has taken over 100 Tests wickets, but has been injured in the last two seasons thanks to that stupid boot camp by Ned Flanders.

I would never rate Mick Lewis in a million years :)

McGain has been their main bowler this year.

Magoffin has been going well and deserved recognition.
 

NUFAN

Y no Afghanistan flag
Benefit of the doubt to a fine Australian bowler who has taken over 100 Tests wickets, but has been injured in the last two seasons thanks to that stupid boot camp by Ned Flanders.

I would never rate Mick Lewis in a million years :)

McGain has been their main bowler this year.

Magoffin has been going well and deserved recognition.
Magoffin is WA and it's pretty hard to argue that McGain has been better then Gerard Denton this year..
 

Richard

Cricket Web Staff Member
Yeah, what's the story with these Peter Siddles, Dirk Nanneses and Clinton McKays? Victoria turning into the Australian equivalent of Yorkshire?
 

MattO

Cricket Spectator
Magoffin is WA and it's pretty hard to argue that McGain has been better then Gerard Denton this year..
Yeah I know Magoffin is WA. He's been the quiet achiever this year. Taking wickets and not getting attention, whereas the likes of Bollinger and Noffke or even spinners like McGain and Hogg are getting lots of attention for their wickets.
 
Last edited:

sideshowtim

Banned
Yeah, what's the story with these Peter Siddles, Dirk Nanneses and Clinton McKays? Victoria turning into the Australian equivalent of Yorkshire?
Siddle is quite a good young talent actually, I really rate him highly. He has just come off an injury, but has performed well with the limited opportunities he's been given. 22 FC wickets at 21 is a pretty damn good start to your career in a competition that is traditionally tricky for younger bowlers and better for batsmen.
 

Top