Fantasy Cricket Player Rankings - Help Needed

[Raghav]

Here is Blackcaps' Gradings

Daniel Vettori (captain) New Zealand D
Shane Bond New Zealand B
Peter Fulton New Zealand C
Mark Gillespie New Zealand C
Gareth Hopkins New Zealand D
Chris Martin New Zealand E
Craig McMillan New Zealand C
Brendon McCullum New Zealand B
Nathan McCullum New Zealand D
Jacob Oram New Zealand C
Jeetan Patel New Zealand C
Bradley Scott New Zealand E
Scott Styris New Zealand A
Ross Taylor New Zealand C
Lou Vincent. New Zealand D

 

[open365]

Shah above Pietersen?

Yup, KP is a rubbish Twenty20 player, Shah is better.

 

[Pup Clarke]

South Africa

Graeme Smith - B
Gulam Bodi - D
Loots Bosman - D
Mark Boucher - B
AB De Villiers - C
JP Duminy - D
Herschelle Gibbs - B
Justin Kemp - C
Albie Morkel - D
Morne Morkel - D
Makhaya Ntini - B
Vernon Philander - D
Shaun Pollock - A
Thandi Tshabalala - D
Johan Van Der Wath - C

West Indies

Ramnaresh Sarwan - B
Dwayne Bravo - C
Shivnarine Chanderpaul - A
Pedro Collins - D
Narsingh Deonarine - E
Fidel Edwards - C
Chris Gayle - B
Runako Morton - D
Daren Powell - C
Denesh Ramdin - D
Ravi Rampaul - D
Darren Sammy - C
Marlon Samuels - C
Devon Smith - D
Dwayne Smith - C

Pakistan

Shoaib Malik - C
Shahid Afridi - C
Shoaib Akthar - B
Kamran Akmal - C
Fawad Alam - C
Yasir Arafat - D
Mohammed Asif - B
Salman Butt - C
Umar Gul - C
Mohammed Hafeez - D
Misbah-ul-Haq - E
Rao Iftikhar - D
Younis Khan - B
Imran Nazir - C
Abdul Rehman - D

 

[readie]

Ricky Ponting (captain) A
Nathan Bracken B
Stuart Clark C
Michael Clarke C
Adam Gilchrist A
Brad Haddin C
Matthew Hayden B
Brad Hodge C
Bradley Hogg D
Michael Hussey A
Mitchell Johnson D
Brett Lee B
Andrew Symonds B
Shaun Tait B
Shane Watson. C
__________________

 

[James]

Here are our final rankings combined with everyone who gave their thoughts.

Final thoughts on them?

 

[Matt79]

Paul Collingwood C
Ravi Bopara C
Stuart Broad D
Andrew Flintoff A
James Kirtley C
Darren Maddy D
Kevin Pietersen C
Matt Prior D
Chris Schofield D
Owais Shah B
Ryan Sidebottom C
Jeremy Snape D
Vikram Solanki C
Chris Tremlett C
Luke Wright D

Flintoff better than all of them? In 2007 as opposed to 2005?

 

[James]

Flintoff better than all of them? In 2007 as opposed to 2005?

What would you rate him as?

 

[Matt79]

These days? Given his likely rustiness and lack of match conditioning at the Cup? A C+, call it a B.

 

[Magrat Garlick]

These days? Given his likely rustiness and lack of match conditioning at the Cup? A C+, call it a B.

Which would still be better than all of them.

 

[Matt79]

Haha - true.

 

[jot1]

There are very few A-ranked players. Is it because 20/20 is new to a lot of the players or are you guys being a bit hard on them?

 

[James]

A bit of both really, was very difficult to rank a lot of the players due to the lack of Twenty20 cricket played to date.