• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official** Sri Lanka v Pakistan in Abu Dhabi

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
Well, I suppose. However, the fact that Australia do something doesn't automatically make it right, and the fact with Hodge remains that he was horrible when he batted #3 - he started to play well in ODI cricket when moved down to #5. Make of it what you will though.
Yeah i know, but the three big factor when you take out what other sides have done and what we have done in the past with new batsmen, is the fact Warnapura is a natural No 3, his got a lot of FC experience and is seen as potential opening option in the future. There more pro, then negs in letting him bat at 3. I see no real reason to hide him down the order.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
We will need good 5 pacies for the Australian tour in Nov.
In november Sri Lanka only plays 2 tests . I can't see the point of taking 5 seamers..because 2 of them are going to be tourists any way...

Given 1 test in Brisbane and 1Test in Hobart...Sri Lanka certainly doesn't need 5 seamers, IMO.

For Brisbane, Sri Lanka may be better off playing 2 spinners. So 3 seamers only needed at Hobart ... So I seriously think SL cricket is better off sending some extra batsmen as part of the Test squad for the early part of the series ie Tests.
(Malinga, Vaas, Dilhara + 1 other should be enough).

When they go back again in Feb for the ODI series they could take extra bowlers.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
Two spinners in Brisbane? Surely not...
Quite possibly the worst ground for spin bowling in world cricket.
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
Two spinners in Brisbane? Surely not...
Quite possibly the worst ground for spin bowling in world cricket.
Warne and MacGill (i think) have got good records there, but we never pick 2nd spinner when we go away, so i seriously doubt we would have one in the sqaud.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
Two spinners in Brisbane? Surely not...
Quite possibly the worst ground for spin bowling in world cricket.
Not if the Sri Lankans win the Toss and Aussies bat last.


Sri Lanka's best shot at winning a Test will be at Brisbane and not Hobart. They can maximise it if they somehow win the Toss and play 2 spinners.

Gabba has been the second best ground in Australia for Spinners after the SCG .(considering Adelaide is quite Flat)
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
Not if the Sri Lankans win the Toss and Aussies bat last.


Sri Lanka's best shot at winning a Test will be at Brisbane and not Hobart. They can maximise it if they somehow win the Toss and play 2 spinners.

Gabba has been the second best ground in Australia for Spinners after the SCG .(considering Adelaide is quite Flat)
If we play two spinners it will mean we will play five bowlers. I can't see Sri Lanka go into a Test match with only Malinga and Vaas as their only seamers, your just asking Malinga to get injuried. Having Lokuarachchi or Maharoof at 7, is way too weak of batting line up. Any advantage you have on the last day will get countered by a weak batting line up or having over worked seamers on the first couple days.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
If we play two spinners it will mean we will play five bowlers. I can't see Sri Lanka go into a Test match with only Malinga and Vaas as their only seamers, your just asking Malinga to get injuried. Having Lokuarachchi or Maharoof at 7, is way too weak of batting line up. Any advantage you have on the last day will get countered by a weak batting line up or having over worked seamers on the first couple days.
You are probably right, and Sanath may end up being the Second spinner.

But we all know Murali likes to bowl long spells, so 2 seamers may be still ok...But I guess it could be harsh if Murali struggles as well, as he can do against the Aussies..

Fair enough...3 seamers then...
 

pup11

International Coach
I think no team would be stupid enough to play 2 spinners at Gabba, and just because Warne and MacGill have good records at Gabba it doesn't mean that its a spinners paradise, Warne and MacGill are high class spinners so they would have good records at most of the grounds, but to expect every spinner to produce similar results to them isn't realistic.
 

PhoenixFire

International Coach
Plus Warne and MacGill turn it much more than any average spinner, especially finger spinners. Actually I think MacGill turns it more than Warne, he just doesn't have Warne's accuracy.
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
I think no team would be stupid enough to play 2 spinners at Gabba, and just because Warne and MacGill have good records at Gabba it doesn't mean that its a spinners paradise, Warne and MacGill are high class spinners so they would have good records at most of the grounds, but to expect every spinner to produce similar results to them isn't realistic.
The thinking has more to do with the fact that the 2nd spinner is greater then the 3rd seamer. So on a pitch that offers the potential of extra turn for spinners as the match goes on, the option would be viable. Regardless of Warne and MacGill records' the Gabba has always been known to offer more support to spinners on day 4 and 5, then most pitches in Australia.
 

pup11

International Coach
There was a bloke called Upul Chandana, now is he still in contention for selection or is he out of favour in Sri Lanka.


IMO, he is a good bowler and a handy bat.
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
There was a bloke called Upul Chandana, now is he still in contention for selection or is he out of favour in Sri Lanka.


IMO, he is a good bowler and a handy bat.
His still in contention but due to his age and lack of consistency outside Sri Lanka, Lokuarachchi and Bandara have jumped ahead of him. He did however make our last Sri Lanka A squad against Bangladesh, as did Rangana Hearth.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
I think no team would be stupid enough to play 2 spinners at Gabba, and just because Warne and MacGill have good records at Gabba it doesn't mean that its a spinners paradise, Warne and MacGill are high class spinners so they would have good records at most of the grounds, but to expect every spinner to produce similar results to them isn't realistic.
So is Murali. He does have good records at most grounds..only he hasn't played in Australian grounds for a long time. Lokuaaratchchi or Bandara can match Macgill on their day.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
The thinking has more to do with the fact that the 2nd spinner is greater then the 3rd seamer. So on a pitch that offers the potential of extra turn for spinners as the match goes on, the option would be viable. Regardless of Warne and MacGill records' the Gabba has always been known to offer more support to spinners on day 4 and 5, then most pitches in Australia.
Exactly my point... If SL were to win Toss and Aussies bat last , that gives SL the best chance of winning a Test in Australia at the Gabba.

As they will need more than a lot of Luck to win at Hobart.
 

JASON

Cricketer Of The Year
There was a bloke called Upul Chandana, now is he still in contention for selection or is he out of favour in Sri Lanka.


IMO, he is a good bowler and a handy bat.
He is an ODI bowler at best, he certainly doesn't turn the ball as much as Bandara or Lokuaarachchi.

I think Chandana's chances of playing for SL are very remote, unless someone gets injured.
 

chaminda_00

Hall of Fame Member
He is an ODI bowler at best, he certainly doesn't turn the ball as much as Bandara or Lokuaarachchi.

I think Chandana's chances of playing for SL are very remote, unless someone gets injured.
TBF Bandara and Lokuarachchi don't turn the ball a great deal either. They are all more top spinners, then anything else. Bandara and Chandana turn their wrong on more then their leg breaks.
 

Top