A.F.L Thread

[Matteh]

Essendon V Collingwood
Port Adelaide V St Kilda
Richmond V West Coast
Sydney V Melbourne
Carlton V Brisbane
Geelong V Kangaroos
Hawthorn V Bulldogs
Fremantle V Adelaide

 

[Jono]

How ****ing good is Pavlich, this man is the next Carey of the competition. Rate him higher than Judd now.

Because he beat a battered Melbourne defence, which is ordinary at the best of times?

Remember what Glass did to him last week?

I rate Pav among the 5 best players in the league, but I don't see how today's performance puts him higher than Judd.

 

[Johnners]

How ****ing good is Pavlich, this man is the next Carey of the competition. Rate him higher than Judd now.

Agreed, although i'd rate him on par with Judd, not quite ahead yet imo.

 

[SirBloody Idiot]

Essendon V Collingwood
Port Adelaide V St Kilda
Richmond V West Coast
Sydney V Melbourne
Carlton V Brisbane
Geelong V Kangaroos
Hawthorn V Bulldogs
Fremantle V Adelaide

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Judd's better for mine.

 

[Hoggy31]

This could be a potentially interesting exercise. Everyone post their top ten favourite players in the league, but they can't play for the team you support...

My list, in no order:

Nick Riewoldt
Nick Dal-Santo
Robert Harvey
Chris Judd
James Hird
Shane Crawford
Sam Mitchell
Nathan G. Brown
Russell Robertson
Scott West

Was thinking today about when we did this a while ago.

In no order:

Matthew Pavlich
Jarrad Rooke
Troy Cook
Cheynee Stiller
Nick Malceski
Tim Clarke
James McDonald
Nathan Foley
Roger Hayden
Scott West

Yeah, cbf doing more, could include every South Freo product going around too.

 

[Hoggy31]

Because he beat a battered Melbourne defence, which is ordinary at the best of times?

Remember what Glass did to him last week?

I rate Pav among the 5 best players in the league, but I don't see how today's performance puts him higher than Judd.

Guess I got a little excited, although Carroll is no mug. Big test this week against Rutten, we'll see how good he is then.

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Carroll's been gun this season, had a shocker today though. Tried hard but Pav was too good.

 

[Jono]

Was thinking today about when we did this a while ago.

In no order:

Matthew Pavlich
Jarrad Rooke
Troy Cook
Cheynee Stiller
Nick Malceski
Tim Clarke
James McDonald
Nathan Foley
Roger Hayden
Scott West

Yeah, cbf doing more, could include every South Freo product going around too.

Nathan Foley... impressive Hoggy. Love him.

Here's mine:

Brett Burton
McLeod
Akermanis
Pavlich
Chad Cornes
Shannon Grant
Lance Franklin
Danyle Pearce
Adam Hunter
Ben Rutten

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Adam Hunter
Matthew Pavlich
Teddy Richards
Delidio
Lenny Hayes
Ben Cousins (stfu)
Lindsay Gilbee
Darren Glass
Luke Hodge
Ryan Crowley

 

[Johnners]

Cameron Bruce
Brett Deledio
Marc Murphy
Andrew McLeod
Russell Robertson
Chris Judd
Tadgh Kennelly (sp?)
Matthew Pavlich
Lance Franklin
Danyle Pearce

 

[pasag]

Judd
Wakelin x2
Chris Grant
Hird
Buckley
Licuria
Robert Murphy
Richo
Pavlich
Maybe Cousins.

Harder than I thought tbh.

 

[vic_orthdox]

Was thinking today about when we did this a while ago.

In no order:

Jarrad Rooke

Max.

Carroll's been gun this season, had a shocker today though. Tried hard but Pav was too good.

Nah, he's been pretty ordinary from what I've seen of him. Admittedly, his side being so bad ATM hasn't helped.

@ all the Melbourne fans up at the snow already.

Anyways, for me...

Murphy
Ted Richards
Jobe Watson
Luke Ball
Delidio
Howat
Matt Spangher
Kerr
Prismall
J. Brown

 

[ash chaulk]

Essendon
St Kilda
West Coast
Melbourne
Brisbane
Geelong
Bulldogs
Adelaide

 

[mikeW]

TOP 10 Fave Players

Paddy Ryder (gun)
Teddy Richards
Danny Jacobs
Bryce Gibbs
Shaun Grigg
Cheynee Stiller
Danyle Pearce
Matthew Pavlich
Chris Judd
Daniel Kerr

 

[Hoggy31]

Pretty sure it was ten favourites outside your club.

 

[Dark Hunter]

Essendon v Collingwood

 

[cameeel]

Essendon v Collingwood

 

[mikeW]

Pretty sure it was ten favourites outside your club.

Goddard instead of Paddy then.

 

[Buddhmaster]

Essendon

Chad Cornes
Cheynee Stiller
Shaun Burgoyne
Marc Murphy
Jim Bartel
Shannon Grant
Paddy Ryder
Brock McLean
Brad Sewell
Ben Cousins

No order, except for Bartel at #1.