Battle of the AFL Stars

[luffy]

Judd

 

[Johnners]

Judd through 10-3

Round 1, Battle 14

Andrew McLeod - Adelaide Crows - Midfield/Halfback

vs.

Warren Tredrea - Port Adelaide Power - Centre Half Foward

 

[Johnners]

McLeod

 

[Hoggy31]

McLeod.

 

[Johnners]

Darren says:
McLeod for mine. Big game player.

 

[pasag]

Hmm, hard one. I have a soft spot for CHF's and Tredrea has been an absolute underrated star for a long time. However McLeod at his best was mesmerising, pure brilliance.

 

[Buddhmaster]

McLeod

Everyone > Tredrea - as a bloke

 

[alternative]

McLeod

 

[chaminda_00]

McLeod

 

[cameeel]

McLeod

 

[Jono]

McLeod, love him. Probably my favourite non-Richmond player other than Carey, Peter Matera and perhaps Burton.

Tredrea's a gun CHF though.

 

[vic_orthdox]

I'm not a big McLeod fan.

But by jiminy I hate Tredrea. So it'll have to be McLeod.

 

[Johnners]

Might as well end this early, McLeod wins 10-zip

Round 1, Battle 15

Brad Johnson - Western Bulldogs - Midfield/Foward Pocket

vs.

Nathan Buckley - Collingwood Magpies/Brisbane Bears - Midfield

 

[Johnners]

Johnson - Possibly my 2nd favourite non-Lions players (Cameron Bruce no.1) and i hate Nathan Buckley with a passion, fully expect him to go through though.

 

[alternative]

Buckley, though i don't like any Collingwood players.

 

[pasag]

Buckley, all time great for mine. Brilliant, brilliant player who would rack up 30 possession game after 30 possession game. Fast, tough, amazing skills and ****ing accurate kicking week in, week out. The best player of this comp for mine and it's a pity he had to be on such a lame team. The consistency of his brilliance is almost unparalleled for mine. And this is coming from a one-eyed Carlton fan as well.

 

[Johnners]

you forgot to mention ugly saggers

 

[Buddhmaster]

Brad Johnson has all the skills and ability you could hope for, and is much more likeable, but i'll give Buckley my vote. Top 5 player of the last 10 years, should go through to the semis.

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Brutal pairing up here, 2 of the better players going round in the comp at the moment.

As much as it pains me to vote against Johnson, Buckley it is.

 

[vic_orthdox]

Buckley, all time great for mine. Brilliant, brilliant player who would rack up 30 possession game after 30 possession game. Fast, tough, amazing skills and ****ing accurate kicking week in, week out. The best player of this comp for mine and it's a pity he had to be on such a lame team. The consistency of his brilliance is almost unparalleled for mine. And this is coming from a one-eyed Carlton fan as well.

Who invited Eddie?

Buckley for mine.