chaminda_00
Hall of Fame Member
Sharks have five players, why do they need more. Tigers have four Morley in for Skando or Gallen IMO.
Also Mark O'Meley?
Also Mark O'Meley?
-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
**Battle of the ARL/NRL Stars**
- Thread starter Blewy
- Start date
Blewy
Cricketer Of The Year
Morley is already in...
Blewy
Cricketer Of The Year
Oh if he gets in so does Jackson Kaufusi...
Simon
Request Your Custom Title Now!
cant agree with that
Simon
Request Your Custom Title Now!
i see your Jackon Kaufusi and raise you a Royston Lightning
pinchy81
International Vice-Captain
oh come on he made it into the Australian team without playing State of Origin surely an acheviement in itself
Blewy
Cricketer Of The Year
Oooh thems fighting words... Well ill see your Roysten and raise you a Lee Murphy...
chaminda_00
Hall of Fame Member
Says more about the his ability to suck up to the then Australian coach, then his ability on the park.
dontcloseyoureyes
BARNES OUT
Girdler should be in there for mine. Could tear a backline apart on his day. One hell of a goalkicker too.
Ahead of Brett Stewart. The guys barely played any football. Girdler played over 200 games and plenty of Origin and international footy.
Ahead of Brett Stewart. The guys barely played any football. Girdler played over 200 games and plenty of Origin and international footy.
Last edited:
dontcloseyoureyes
BARNES OUT
Also, Paul Rauhihi?
dontcloseyoureyes
BARNES OUT
Sonny Bill WIlliams? Benji Marshall? They've played collectively like a season between them. These guys ahead of players like Renouf and Girdler is a joke.
Blewy
Cricketer Of The Year
Marshall and SBW are rated among the games top 5-10 players now, how could they be left out...
Its clear how much impact Marshall has on the Tigers, yes he may not have played a great amount but that doesnt hide the fact that he is a class act and deserves to be in this list...
Johnners
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Hmmmmmmmmm.....
i can see names i'd take out....
Benji - A talent no doubt, but sheesh, has hardly put 5 games together without being injured
Ali Lauiti'ti - Has 1 good year, 1 Gun year, then left
Sonny Bill - See Benji
Brett Stewart - One Gun year last year, thats it
Paul Gallen - See Brett Stewart
Matt Orford - Had 1 good year last year, but has done not much else, apart from be overrated. Should'n't be ahead of Toovey, Taylor
Justin Hodges - He's good, but no way should he be there ahead of Renouf, Girdler, Mullins or Brasher.
Timana Tahu - See Hodges
Paul Bowman - See Hodges
Ben Hornby - See Hodges
Preston Campbell - He's good, but hasn't done it consistently enough. Shouldn't be ahead of Taylor, Toovey
i can see names i'd take out....
Benji - A talent no doubt, but sheesh, has hardly put 5 games together without being injured
Ali Lauiti'ti - Has 1 good year, 1 Gun year, then left
Sonny Bill - See Benji
Brett Stewart - One Gun year last year, thats it
Paul Gallen - See Brett Stewart
Matt Orford - Had 1 good year last year, but has done not much else, apart from be overrated. Should'n't be ahead of Toovey, Taylor
Justin Hodges - He's good, but no way should he be there ahead of Renouf, Girdler, Mullins or Brasher.
Timana Tahu - See Hodges
Paul Bowman - See Hodges
Ben Hornby - See Hodges
Preston Campbell - He's good, but hasn't done it consistently enough. Shouldn't be ahead of Taylor, Toovey
Last edited:
Johnners
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Talent wise they're rated among the best, but until the put it together for more than half a season there is no way they should be ahead of Girdler, Mullins, Brasher, Toovey, Renouf, Taylor, Matthew Ridge.
Buddhmaster
International Captain
Girdler should be in just for being such a great bloke.
steds
Hall of Fame Member
Blaze
Banned
Ridge should definetly be there.
Clapo - Ali Lauiti'ti was freakish in 2002, and was consistantly good before that. He has to be one of the strangest players in rugby league though. How can a guy who was that good be so **** now?
Benji has to be there as well. The Tigers wouldn't have won the premiership without him. His influence on his team mates (and the NRL) is huge, and he is still only very young.
SBW is borderline. He was imense in the 03 GF and has been awesome everytime he has played for NZ but he still has a bit more to prove than Benji imo.
Clapo - Ali Lauiti'ti was freakish in 2002, and was consistantly good before that. He has to be one of the strangest players in rugby league though. How can a guy who was that good be so **** now?
Benji has to be there as well. The Tigers wouldn't have won the premiership without him. His influence on his team mates (and the NRL) is huge, and he is still only very young.
SBW is borderline. He was imense in the 03 GF and has been awesome everytime he has played for NZ but he still has a bit more to prove than Benji imo.
BoyBrumby
Englishman
Was he playing for Penrith or Easts that day?
Johnners
Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
I'm not denying that Lauiti'ti had a gun 02, but imo he wasn't one of the top 10 backrowers in the years before hand.
Benji has played one good season, he's been injured for the rest. There is no way he should make the list ahead of Toovey, Taylor, Ridge, Mullins, Brasher, Darryl Halligan, Renouf & Girdler.
SBW shouldn't be there. He didn't play in the 03 grand final
and has played a few awesome games, but has done little else but pose for advertisements, and walk around with crutches or his arm in a sling. If a few gun games is criterea then hell, put Brett Finch in.