Which off these ATG XIs from different eras will win a tournament if they competed with each other?

[ankitj]

Distinct lack of Zaheer Abbas.

 

[Krypto]

2 Wins this for me hands down , even a alternative team here will do very well . However ill have Warne in for Murali and will change batting lineup with Kallis excluded to have a bit more balanced batting with only lara batting out of position and Waugh coming in at 5 (You can have ul-Haq or Ranatunga as well to fill same role ) batting option and a more ODI focused player. This era suffers from not having a specialist no 4 which means you have Lara , Kallis and Ponting all bidding for no 3 and ill much rather have Lara out of position than Kallis or Ponting thus Kallis moves out . You can also use Hayden as opener and move Tendulkar to 5 however that feels sacrilegious .

Tendulkar
Gilchrist +
Ponting *
Lara
Steve Waugh
Bevan

 

[Fuller Pilch]

I'd go

Era 1: 1971 - 1992

Greenidge
Haynes
Richards
Jones
Z Abbas
Imran *
Kapil
Hadlee
Smith+
Garner
Qadir

Era 2: 1992 - 2007

Tendulkar
Gilchrist +
Jayasuriya
Ponting *
Lara
Bevan
Klusener
Pollock
Wasim
Murali
McGrath

Era 3: 2007 - 2023

Rohit
Watson
Kohli
AB de Villiers
R Taylor
Dhoni + *
Shakib
Starc
Malinga
Tahir
Bumrah


I think era 2 would win.

 

[Krypto]

I'd go

Era 1: 1971 - 1992

Greenidge
Haynes
Richards
Jones
Z Abbas
Imran *
Kapil
Hadlee
Smith+
Garner
Qadir

Era 2: 1992 - 2007

Tendulkar
Gilchrist +
Jayasuriya
Ponting *
Lara
Bevan
Klusener
Pollock
Wasim
Murali
McGrath

Era 3: 2007 - 2023

Rohit
Watson
Kohli
AB de Villiers
R Taylor
Dhoni + *
Shakib
Starc
Malinga
Tahir
Bumrah


I think era 2 would win.

Agreed on era 2 however must admit that era is incredibly difficult to get balance on top order . You have Ponting at 4 however he batted 3 for 330 out of 365 innings and Jayasuriya at 3 however he opened 383 out of 433 innings . I had the same issue when looking at that eras batting , way to many great top order bats , openers and number 3s .