What is your best non-ATG XI?

[Thala_0710]

Barry Richards
Herbert Sutcliffe
Clem Hill
Steve Smith
Graeme Pollock
Allan Border
Don Tallon
Ravi Ashwin
Vernon Philander
Alan Davidson
Harold Larwood

Steve Smith not being an ATG is doing my head.

 

[Johan]

Hmmm. Excluding current players as always

Geoff Boycott
Graeme Smith*
Hashim Amla
Neil Harvey
Peter May
Frank Worrell
AB de Villiers+
Andy Roberts
Alec Bedser
Derek Underwood
Neil Adcock

Tough choices were keeper and spinner

Knott I feel deserves to be classed as ATG. So AB was the best batsman who was a quality keeper though only part time. Otherwise perhaps Flower. If I went for a more traditional keeper off the top of my head perhaps Marsh.

Spinner was tough to draw the line between the 4th place contestants for spinners and ATG level. So sucks to be you deadly. I guess this is me saying Ashwin and those other blokes are all ATG. Could go Gibbs another day

Wow Trueman's so bad he didn't even make your non ATG team?

 

[Fuller Pilch]

Barry Richards
Herbert Sutcliffe
Clem Hill
Steve Smith
Graeme Pollock
Allan Border
Don Tallon
Ravi Ashwin
Vernon Philander
Alan Davidson
Harold Larwood

As Woakesy is an ATG, this is one team he can't make.