Sachin. Sobers. Smith.

[DrWolverine]

Rank them as test batsmen

 

[Johan]

Sobers
Smith
Sachin

 

[vidiq]

Sobers 57.78
Smith 56.74

Sachin 53.78

 

[Thala_0710]

Sachin
Smith
Sobers

 

[subshakerz]

I have Sachin Sobers Smith but Smith now has some good arguments against Sobers.

 

[subshakerz]

Sobers
Smith
Sachin

What is Sobers advantage against the other two?

 

[Johan]

What is Sobers advantage against the other two?

Batting.

 

[ma1978]

Sobers 57.78
Smith 56.74

Sachin 53.78

is stupidity a justification for banning a poster

 

[Johan]

is stupidity a justification for banning a poster

why so angry

 

[Johan]

What is Sobers advantage against the other two?

tho, he is more successful against ATG bowlers he faced than the other two, he is more consistent than Smith but has one less ATG away tour, I don't think Smith's output would be anywhere near Sobers by the time Smith retires. Sachin respectfully is just longevity, which I put under Greatness as a Cricketer and not batting quality once you meet a threshold.

 

[govinda indian fan]

tho, he is more successful against ATG bowlers he faced than the other two, he is more consistent than Smith but has one less ATG away tour, I don't think Smith's output would be anywhere near Sobers by the time Smith retires. Sachin respectfully is just longevity, which I put under Greatness as a Cricketer and not batting quality once you meet a threshold.

Sachin atlest did well vs ambrose warne, Murali and styen. Smith is average vs 3 atg quick bowlers he faced(styen bumrah and rabada)

 

[govinda indian fan]

Smith has atg series (17 bgt) vs two atvg spinners he faced(ash and jadeja) but became ashwin`s bunny in 20/21 and 23 bgt

 

[vidiq]

Sachin atlest did well vs ambrose warne, Murali and styen. Smith is average vs 3 atg quick bowlers he faced(styen bumrah and rabada)

Smith also dominated aswin and Jadeja, which you always forget to mention.

 

[vidiq]

Smith has atg series (17 bgt) vs two atvg spinners he faced(ash and jadeja) but became ashwin`s bunny in 20/21 and 23 bgt

You have already posted the same thing so many times in this sub forum.

 

[sayon basak]

You have already posted the same thing so many times in this sub forum.

Ironic isn't it?

 

[Thala_0710]

Ironic isn't it?

Govinda vs Narayan would be a rivalry for the ages especially with Subs vs Kyear losing its charm.

 

[govinda indian fan]

Govinda vs Narayan would be a rivalry for the ages especially with Subs vs Kyear losing its charm.

He is trying to malign sachin for his fav steve smith anyway i was replaying to @Johan who said sachin has nothing except longevity lol

 

[Johan]

Sachin atlest did well vs ambrose warne, Murali and styen. Smith is average vs 3 atg quick bowlers he faced(styen bumrah and rabada)

Won't say he dominated Murali, Murali only really got good around 1998 when he bowled that Oval Spell, after that Sachin averages 33 in games with Murali in 12 games, Murali got him 6/18 after 98. Warne and Steyn are fair enough. I said Sobers is more dominant against great fast bowling and that's factual, I never commented on Sachin vs Smith against elite bowling.

 

[govinda indian fan]

Won't say he dominated Murali, Murali only really got good around 1998 when he bowled that Oval Spell, after that Sachin averages 33 in games with Murali in 12 games, Murali got him 6/18 after 98. Warne and Steyn are fair enough. I said Sobers is better than the other two against the great bowlers he faced (Trueman, Davidson, Lillee) and that's factual, I never commented on Sachin vs Smith against elite bowling.

Sachin figures vs murali got hurt by 05 home series(when he was at his lowest point in his career) and 08 sl tour ( sachin got out to mendis not Murali) otherwise pretty good

 

[govinda indian fan]

Its shame sachin missed 01 tour to sl. Peak murali vs peak sachin