Interesting LBW's and Edges That Shouldn't Have or Should Have Been Out

[tshep]

Hey guys.

I wanna see if you guys have some really bad LBW or edging decisions that shouldn't have or should've been out. I know in the book 'Finding Seams On Apples' when i read it it said something in the topic 'Weirdest dismissals in Cricket' about an LBW that meant a guy having a bruise on his ribs. I also remember in the Ashes Usman Khawaja was out, reviewed and clearly had not got bat on ball but still walked away out for some single digit number. Please do not say that KP was not out in the Ashes because there was evidence of contact from his.

Anyway enough of me talking, lets hear your replies (I'll accept run outs too)

 

[robelinda]

 

[robelinda]

 

[Captain_Cook]

Are you serious? There are occasions every match where this happened.

If you are serious this is the start of a huge list:

• Harbhajan SIngh given LBW in Stuart Broad's Test hatrick in 2011 despite getting a huge inside edge.
• Adam Gilchrist given LBW in Harbhajan Singh's Test hatrick in 2001 despite getting a huge inside edge.
• Sachin Tendulkar given LBW after crouching and hit on the shoulder by a short ball that stayed low but was obviously going over the stumps.

 

[NUFAN]

Why the **** do your polls have nothing to do with your threads?

 

[Riggins]

what ****ster makes a thread 4 this?

 

[Daemon]

The most important thing to come out of this is that there are actually non members who have bought the book.

 

[benchmark00]

Hey guys.

I wanna see if you guys have some really bad LBW or edging decisions that shouldn't have or should've been out. I know in the book 'Finding Seams On Apples' when i read it it said something in the topic 'Weirdest dismissals in Cricket' about an LBW that meant a guy having a bruise on his ribs. I also remember in the Ashes Usman Khawaja was out, reviewed and clearly had not got bat on ball but still walked away out for some single digit number. Please do not say that KP was not out in the Ashes because there was evidence of contact from his.

Anyway enough of me talking, lets hear your replies (I'll accept run outs too)

 

[uvelocity]

The most important thing to come out of this is that there are actually non members who have bought the book.

no they havent

 

[Riggins]

no they havent

i was gonna write that too.

 

[uvelocity]

wheres your positions thread gone. teased by the title and missed it

 

[benchmark00]

It was mine ****.

And lol, someone deleted it.

 

[uvelocity]

cliffs?

 

[benchmark00]

Wheelbarrow style won.

 

[uvelocity]

definiely a fave

 

[Goughy]

[*]Sachin Tendulkar given LBW after crouching and hit on the shoulder by a short ball that stayed low but was obviously going over the stumps.
[/LIST]

That was out and even if it wasn't, it was damn close.

 

[Top_Cat]

Yeah, FFS. Terrible example.

 

[Burgey]

Simon Jones lbw Lee, second dig, second Ashes test 2005. Hit on the back shin on the full in front of middle. Bizarre decision.

 

[robelinda]

 

[robelinda]