shortpitched713
Cricketer Of The Year
We want to do this duel guys? @kyear2 @subshakerz
My thought was that you guys could channel your cricket debating prowess towards a single issue of interest, in an organized, judged debate.
So something like a scoring system 0-10 based on each criteria below:
1: Soundness of position presented - Do you make the case in a logical and organized manner that others could get behind
2: Quality of argumentation - How you interact with the argument presented by opponent
3: Evidence provided - Quantity and quality of evidence provided
We could get 3 judges like boxing, have them score each participant 0-30, and the judges decision would determine the winner.
Format could be something like opening presentation, 2 rebuttals each, then question from each of the judges, followed by 2 rebuttals each for each question, then closing. IDK, it's all kind of fluid as an idea.
If you all do want to do it, I'd suggest a 50/50 topic, i.e. not one of the ones each of y'all get lampooned on, but maybe something more plausible for either side, lol.
My thought was that you guys could channel your cricket debating prowess towards a single issue of interest, in an organized, judged debate.
So something like a scoring system 0-10 based on each criteria below:
1: Soundness of position presented - Do you make the case in a logical and organized manner that others could get behind
2: Quality of argumentation - How you interact with the argument presented by opponent
3: Evidence provided - Quantity and quality of evidence provided
We could get 3 judges like boxing, have them score each participant 0-30, and the judges decision would determine the winner.
Format could be something like opening presentation, 2 rebuttals each, then question from each of the judges, followed by 2 rebuttals each for each question, then closing. IDK, it's all kind of fluid as an idea.
If you all do want to do it, I'd suggest a 50/50 topic, i.e. not one of the ones each of y'all get lampooned on, but maybe something more plausible for either side, lol.
