• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official*** India Tour of South Africa, 2023/24

Spark

Global Moderator
How does that hack fraud keep getting jobs? It's like once you're in the coaching establishment you will always find work despite lack of demonstrated results.
Being credited with "teaching" an on-paper world class attack to use reverse swing in one series, something Pakistani bowlers had been doing for decades, is enough to land you two decades of failing upwards it seems.
 

Starfighter

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Being credited with "teaching" an on-paper world class attack to use reverse swing in one series, something Pakistani bowlers had been doing for decades, is enough to land you two decades of failing upwards it seems.
And we know the major trick behind it was ball tampering too.
 

Dendarii

International Debutant
Wouldn't be the first time someone jumped the queue in test cricket..I mean Klaasen was supposed to be the keeper Conrad was gonna back then he goes back to Kyle Verrynne , others like Linde , Pieter Malan didnt do a whole lot wrong and got dropped ..
Besides you can't get worse than the message we sent to the world when we announced the squad to NZ.
That's squad selection, which is a different scenario from bringing someone from outside of a squad straight into a team. And the message is the message to players, not other countries as they couldn't care less about the way squads are managed.
 

Spark

Global Moderator
Krishna turns 28 in six weeks, he's not really that young.
Natarajan has not played fc since Gabba
Even worse then!

I genuinely thought the likes of Umesh, Shami, Bumrah were going to be the heralds of a new era of consistent Indian fast bowling, but the lot they're turning to now makes me wonder if the Wheel is returning with a vengeance.
 

Silver Silva

International Regular
Team loses by an innings..
Team Selectors : "Let's drop two bowlers"

I really feel India should have been more pragmatic, make yourself hard to beat play an extra batsman or play Ashwin and Jadeja together and rotate 3 seamers there is enough in the SA pitches for 3 seamers willing to toil to get the rewards , what we learnt in Centurion is that you don't need lots of pacers you just need consistency from 2 or 3 it's the runs that dictate the game.
 

Socerer 01

International Captain
Team loses by an innings..
Team Selectors : "Let's drop two bowlers"

I really feel India should have been more pragmatic, make yourself hard to beat play an extra batsman or play Ashwin and Jadeja together and rotate 3 seamers there is enough in the SA pitches for 3 seamers willing to toil to get the rewards , what we learnt in Centurion is that you don't need lots of pacers you just need consistency from 2 or 3 it's the runs that dictate the game.
generous calling Thakur a bowler
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
And that's not too shabby a start, especially considering these two have to do heavy liftings as the other two pacers are Mukesh and ****ing Prasidh....
 

Starfighter

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Even worse then!

I genuinely thought the likes of Umesh, Shami, Bumrah were going to be the heralds of a new era of consistent Indian fast bowling, but the lot they're turning to now makes me wonder if the Wheel is returning with a vengeance.
They might also have been relying on guys like Nagarkoti and Mavi turning into something other than a reliable source of income for sports doctors and physiotherapists.

But you can't plan around certain future bowlers (imagine if we'd had to plan around James Pattinson, or Cummins for the first several years of his career) and need to maximise what you've got. Natarajan showed that, while he mightn't ever be a great bowler, he's got some skills and some smarts. Unless he's been really injured it's crazy he hasn't played FC since.
 

Stefan9

International Debutant
Wouldn't be the first time someone jumped the queue in test cricket..I mean Klaasen was supposed to be the keeper Conrad was gonna back then he goes back to Kyle Verrynne , others like Linde , Pieter Malan didnt do a whole lot wrong and got dropped ..
Besides you can't get worse than the message we sent to the world when we announced the squad to NZ.
Those are players who were dropped from the squad..not players brought in from the outside and leaping ahead of someone in the squad.
Last we did that was the Zondo/Elgar ODI incident. Do we really want a repeat?
 

Socerer 01

International Captain
They might also have been relying on guys like Nagarkoti and Mavi turning into something other than a reliable source of income for sports doctors and physiotherapists.

But you can't plan around certain future bowlers (imagine if we'd had to plan around James Pattinson, or Cummins for the first several years of his career) and need to maximise what you've got. Natarajan showed that, while he mightn't ever be a great bowler, he's got some skills and some smarts. Unless he's been really injured it's crazy he hasn't played FC since.
he has been injured though man is made of same material as Nagarkoti
 

Silver Silva

International Regular
generous calling Thakur a bowler
Thakur is lacking confidence he had a good tour of SA last time out but this would have been my side for Newlands Test :

1.Rohit
2.Jaiswal
3.Easwaran
4.Kohli
5.Gill
6.Rahul (WK)
7.Jadeja
8.Ashwin
9.Avesh Khan
10.Jasprit Bumrah
11.Mohammad Siraj
 

Top