• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Keith Miller vs Michael Atherton

Who is the better test batsman?

  • Total voters
    25
shortpitched713

shortpitched713

International Captain
Atherton almost certainly a better Test batsman.

The real question though is, are either a top 80 batsman of all time?

Edit: If you say no to either, then please list every Test batsman better than the aforementioned, otherwise I will be forced to consider your I'll conceived opinion null and void, and bid you a good day.
 
capt_Luffy

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
shortpitched713 said:
Atherton almost certainly a better Test batsman.

The real question though is, are either a top 80 batsman of all time?

Edit: If you say no to either, then please list every Test batsman better than the aforementioned, otherwise I will be forced to consider your I'll conceived opinion null and void, and bid you a good day.
Click to expand...
1. Bradman
2. Sobers
3. Tendulkar
4. Hobbs
5. Lara
6. Gavaskar
7. Viv Richards
8. Hutton
9. Hammond
10. Steve Smith
11. George Headley
12. H Sutcliffe
13. G Pollock
14. G Chappell
15. Dravid
16. Steve Waugh
17. Ponting
18. Kallis
19. Border
20. Sangakkara
21. Weekes
22. Barrington
23. Walcott
24. Barry Richards
25. Trumper
26. Andy Flower
27. D Nourse
28. De Villiers
29. Harvey
30. Worrell
31. Kohli
32. Root
33. Williamson
34. Miandad
35. Younis Khan
36. Kanhai
37. Compton
38. Boycott
39. Lloyd
40. Hayden
41. Sehwag
42. Greenidge
43. Graeme Smith
44. Aravinda De Silva
45. M Crowe
46. Jayawardene
47. Laxman
48. May
49. McCabe
50. W G Grace
51. Ranjitsinhji
52. A Morris
53. Simpson
54. Cowdrey
55. Gooch
56. Cook
57. Chanderpaul
58. Pietersen
59. Amla
60. M Clarke
61. C Hill
62. Ponsford
63. Charlie McCartney
64. Arthur Shrewsbury
65. B Mitchell
66. G Kirsten
67. Lawry
68. Hazare
69. Md Yousuf
70. Hanif
71. Norman O'Neil
72. M Waugh
73. Boon
74. Langer
75. Richardson
76. Rowe
77. C Hunte
78. Kalicharan
79. D Walters
80. Z Abbas
81. H Gibbs
82. G Turner
83. Labuschagne
84. Pujara
85. Vishwanath
86. C Washbrook
87. Gower
88. Dexter
89. Graveney
90. Stanley Jackson
91. E Paynter
92. Leyland
93. D Jardine
94. S Nurse
95. Thorpe
96. Azharuddin
97. S Ganguly
98. J Edrich
99. D Amiss
100. Jack Ryder
101. I Chappell
102. P Hendren
103. I Bell
104. Babar Azam
105. Inzamam
106. E Barlow
107. J McGlew
108. H Taylor
109. R Taylor
110. M Taylor
111. B Sutcliffe
112. A Strauss
113. S Fleming
114. D Warner
115. Robin Smith
116. Alan Lamb
117. M Slater
118. Archie Jackson
119. Archie Maclaren
120. Dean Jones
121. Murdoch
122. Roy Fredericks
123. Stewart
124. Vaughan
125. Lindsay Hassett
125 players better batsmen than Keith Miller (could go on for few more) and atleast 100 better than Mike Atherton
 
Last edited:
capt_Luffy

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
ataraxia said:
Hassett's about 75 too low there
Click to expand...
It's not a ranking.... I was ranking them at first then went by whichever name I thought up randomly. Though I placed Hassett there quite intentionally as he was the vice captain in the 'Invincibles', and was clearly a more important batsman in there than Miller
 
shortpitched713

shortpitched713

International Captain
capt_Luffy said:
1. Bradman
2. Sobers
3. Tendulkar
4. Hobbs
5. Lara
6. Gavaskar
7. Viv Richards
8. Hutton
9. Hammond
10. Steve Smith
11. George Headley
12. H Sutcliffe
13. G Pollock
14. G Chappell
15. Dravid
16. Steve Waugh
17. Ponting
18. Kallis
19. Border
20. Sangakkara
21. Weekes
22. Barrington
23. Walcott
24. Barry Richards
25. Trumper
26. Andy Flower
27. D Nourse
28. De Villiers
29. Harvey
30. Worrell
31. Kohli
32. Root
33. Williamson
34. Miandad
35. Younis Khan
36. Kanhai
37. Compton
38. Boycott
39. Lloyd
40. Hayden
41. Sehwag
42. Greenidge
43. Graeme Smith
44. Aravinda De Silva
45. M Crowe
46. Jayawardene
47. Laxman
48. May
49. McCabe
50. W G Grace
51. Ranjitsinhji
52. A Morris
53. Simpson
54. Cowdrey
55. Gooch
56. Cook
57. Chanderpaul
58. Pietersen
59. Amla
60. M Clarke
61. C Hill
62. Ponsford
63. Charlie McCartney
64. Arthur Shrewsbury
65. B Mitchell
66. G Kirsten
67. Lawry
68. Hazare
69. Md Yousuf
70. Hanif
71. Norman O'Neil
72. M Waugh
73. Boon
74. Langer
75. Richardson
76. Rowe
77. C Hunte
78. Kalicharan
79. D Walters
80. Z Abbas
81. H Gibbs
82. G Turner
83. Labuschagne
84. Pujara
85. Vishwanath
86. C Washbrook
87. Gower
88. Dexter
89. Graveney
90. Stanley Jackson
91. E Paynter
92. Leyland
93. D Jardine
94. S Nurse
95. Thorpe
96. Azharuddin
97. S Ganguly
98. J Edrich
99. D Amiss
100. Jack Ryder
101. I Chappell
102. P Hendren
103. I Bell
104. Babar Azam
105. Inzamam
106. E Barlow
107. J McGlew
108. H Taylor
109. R Taylor
110. M Taylor
111. B Sutcliffe
112. A Strauss
113. S Fleming
114. D Warner
115. Robin Smith
116. Alan Lamb
117. M Slater
118. Archie Jackson
119. Archie Maclaren
120. Dean Jones
121. Murdoch
122. Roy Fredericks
123. Stewart
124. Vaughan
125. Lindsay Hasseett
125 players better batsmen then Keith Miller (could go on for few more) and atleast 100 better than Mike Atherton
Click to expand...
The madlad actually did it!:laugh:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top