ataraxia
International Coach
I'd bat him up the order over 21-skilled Badenhorst. I'm not sure that opening with Jalal Farhat is the best of ideas. Defiant + much better Agg than Def is annoying, preferably try to train him up in Agg/SS until he gets to steady aggression. Iceman might make Farhat a better player at #5 or #6. Hetal Tyagi is a slow starter but has high Agg, I'd be inclined to bat him lower down in SODs.He is my best bat by 1 point over Kock, who is better defensive player. Hence I tend to play Kock above Tigwell in the big games. My openers are my next best players. And Tyagi gets 3 because of the slow starter characteristic. Katz gets the lower order because of the finisher characteristic.
Tigwell only gets to play the occasional game anyway. He has been great for me but he is largely there for big games until Mthombeni gets his wk skill up.
I'd probably have Kock at #3, Tigwell at #4, but I'm hardly more experienced with the game than you.