-
Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.
You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.
The ATG Teams General arguing/discussing thread
- Thread starter Red
- Start date
ankitj
Hall of Fame Member
Now do it for spinners to compliment Bagapath's table.
ankitj
Hall of Fame Member
Sydney Barnes was not part of either table?
Magrat Garlick
Rather Mad Witch
brumby to respond
srbhkshk
International Captain
Murali , Warne and who else?
ankitj
Hall of Fame Member
Kumble, Herath, Ashwin may be
honestbharani
Whatever it takes!!!
We could do one for contemporary spinners - Ashwin,, Lyon, Yasir, Jadeja, Moeen, maybe few others I am missing?
I just came across below article. I thought Warne always rated Sachin as the best ever by a country mile. His comments in below interview (rating Viv as the best ever he has seen, or hard to imagine anyone better than Viv etc.) were pretty surprising.
www.indiatoday.in
Tough to think anyone is better than Viv Richards but Virat Kohli pushing that conversation: Shane Warne
Leg-spin great Shane Warne also said Steve Smith should not focus on Australia captaincy at the moment in order to avoid any distractions.
GoodAreasShane
Cricketer Of The Year
Warne never bowled to Viv in international cricket, not sure if he did in any serious game tbhI just came across below article. I thought Warne always rated Sachin as the best ever by a country mile. His comments in below interview (rating Viv as the best ever he has seen, or hard to imagine anyone better than Viv etc.) were pretty surprising.
Tough to think anyone is better than Viv Richards but Virat Kohli pushing that conversation: Shane Warne
Leg-spin great Shane Warne also said Steve Smith should not focus on Australia captaincy at the moment in order to avoid any distractions.
Red
The normal awards that everyone else has
"Viv is the best batsman I have ever seen. Sachin (Tendulkar) and (Brian) Lara are the two best batters I have played with and now across all formats Virat is just the best. It is tough to think anyone is better than Viv but Virat is pushing that conversation,"
trundler
Request Your Custom Title Now!
All the guys one would expect. ****ing click bait
CricAddict
Cricketer Of The Year
Hi friends, I am interested to know how people here in the forum rate ATGs in ODIs. Please rank them as per how you rate people. If you are interested and most of you post on it, I can total them and provide it here to see the collective view.
Below are some of the criteria I could think of. If possible, please provide the weightage as well when you rank them.
1. Batting/Bowling average
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate
3. Longevity
4. Clutch performances
5. World Cup performance
6. World Cup knock-out performance
7. World Cup final performance
8. Viewing perception
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics
Below are some of the criteria I could think of. If possible, please provide the weightage as well when you rank them.
1. Batting/Bowling average
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate
3. Longevity
4. Clutch performances
5. World Cup performance
6. World Cup knock-out performance
7. World Cup final performance
8. Viewing perception
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics
CricAddict
Cricketer Of The Year
Here is mine.
1. Viewing perception (30%) - I rate people more if I have watched them play and being a fan of them
2. Batting/Bowling average (20%) - Average*Strike rate is an important measure for me
3. Batting/Bowling strike-rate (15%)
4. Longevity (15%) - Definitely one to be appreciated. Not easy to be selected in an international team for a long time without being good
5. Clutch performances (15%) - Be it in WC or outside, out of the world performances and performances in pressure situation
6. World Cup performance (5%)
1. Viewing perception (30%) - I rate people more if I have watched them play and being a fan of them
2. Batting/Bowling average (20%) - Average*Strike rate is an important measure for me
3. Batting/Bowling strike-rate (15%)
4. Longevity (15%) - Definitely one to be appreciated. Not easy to be selected in an international team for a long time without being good
5. Clutch performances (15%) - Be it in WC or outside, out of the world performances and performances in pressure situation
6. World Cup performance (5%)
bagapath
International Captain
1. Batting/Bowling average 25
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate 20
3. Longevity 5
4. Clutch performances 10
5. World Cup performance 5
6. World Cup knock-out performance 5
7. World Cup final performance 5
8. Viewing perception 10
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics 5
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics 10
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate 20
3. Longevity 5
4. Clutch performances 10
5. World Cup performance 5
6. World Cup knock-out performance 5
7. World Cup final performance 5
8. Viewing perception 10
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics 5
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics 10
honestbharani
Whatever it takes!!!
1. Batting/Bowling average - 25%
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate - 25%
3. Longevity - 15%
4. Clutch performances - 15%
5. World Cup performance - 10%
6. World Cup knock-out performance - 5%
7. World Cup final performance - 5%
8. Viewing perception
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics
The last 3 are not objective so I am not giving it any consideration if we are doing a statistical exercise.
2. Batting/Bowling strike-rate - 25%
3. Longevity - 15%
4. Clutch performances - 15%
5. World Cup performance - 10%
6. World Cup knock-out performance - 5%
7. World Cup final performance - 5%
8. Viewing perception
9. Hearsay from famous cricketers/critics
10. Batting/Bowling Aesthetics
The last 3 are not objective so I am not giving it any consideration if we are doing a statistical exercise.