*Official* Third Test at Old Trafford

[LegionOfBrad]

Looks like more rain at lunch.

 

[Howe_zat]

That's exactly the same as the Smith decision on day one. Not out then, out today. Tosh.

I think both were out ftr

 

[cover drive man]

Again, snicko yes, hotspur no. Starting to think hotspur is pretty hopeless with faint edges.

 

[Cabinet96]

That had to be out though. What else could it have been?

Yeah, I'm a DRS fan boy in general, but ones like that are the main flaw with the system. Since hotspot doesn't show all faint edges, it's really hard to get an out caught behind reversed unless there is daylight.

 

[Son Of Coco]

Still don't think he hit that. There was a noise, but didn't sound woody.

Sounded like an edge to me.

 

[NUFAN]

Siddy moves into 80th spot all time! Outstanding, imagine if Clarke had of taken Root too.

 

[benchmark00]

Still don't think he hit that. There was a noise, but didn't sound woody.

Are you genuinely serious? Don't know how much more you need.

 

[ajdude]

don't think he hit that tbh

you guys are talking about khawaja right?

 

[Swingpanzee]

What about airflow?

 

[Son Of Coco]

Yeah, I'm a DRS fan boy in general, but ones like that are the main flaw with the system. Since hotspot doesn't show all faint edges, it's really hard to get an out caught behind reversed unless there is daylight.

Even then it's nigh on impossible.

 

[Ruckus]

Siddle bowling like a dream. Need him and Harris in tandem.

 

[grecian]

Fair enough decision really. Used all our reviews now, bound to **** us up sometime the way this series has gone.

 

[Spikey]

nasser talking good stuff re hotspot. shane warne is not

 

[andyc]

See. Out.

Can I continue my stance? Hot spot out, snicko in.

Hot Spot still has its uses, but as the comms have said it'll miss a few. I'd much rather both used in conjunction, with something on Snicko being enough evidence even if there's nothing on Hot Spot.

 

[Cabinet96]

That's exactly the same as the Smith decision on day one. Not out then, out today. Tosh.

I think both were out ftr

Nah come on. First of all it's different because of the on field decision. Secondly the noise with the Smith one was after it passed the bat. And not one of those, half a frame ones, it was about three or four frames.

 

[Pothas]

Harris and Siddle been brilliant this morning.

 

[morgieb]

That's exactly the same as the Smith decision on day one. Not out then, out today. Tosh.

I think both were out ftr

One was given by the ump, the other wasn't. Not hard to understand IMO.

 

[MW1304]

I've never seen so many edges that haven't shown up on hotspot in a series. Surely climate must affect it or something.

 

[Cabinet96]

See. Out.

Can I continue my stance? Hot spot out, snicko in.

No reason to chose one, best situation is both in harmony. But yes, snicko has to come in ASAP.

 

[stephen]

That was far more out than Khawaja. The sound sounded correct and it looked like a tiny little feather.