***Official*** Sri Lanka in Australia 2012/2013

[DriveClub]

One of the commentators said that it helps batsmen who are looking to survive, which I agree with.

Batsmen are more aware of protecting the straight balls from getting out LBW, when they are looking to defend. So they get their pads outside the line and make sure the bat is in-line, therefore the ball impacts in-line and it hits the bat, or it hits the pad and its outside the line.

Watching live this is not noticeable and umpires give them out, but with DRS it is very hard to get an out decision if the batsmen use this tactic.

So you think decisions should favour bowlers if the batsmen are trying to survive by giving wrong decisions? In the same way DRS helps bowlers if batsmen try to bat outside the crease in case of LBWs. It works both ways, in the end it certainly balances out, I don't see neither batsmen or bowlers benefiting from DRS, Channel 9 commies were on their jingoistic trip as usual when we looked like we couldn't bowl out SL.

 

[LongHopCassidy]

IMO sides should only get one DRS call per innings instead of two. It was there to eliminate the howlers and nothing more; it ****s me to tears when batsmen call for referrals because of the match situation or how valuable their own wicket is.

Case in point was Siddle's hat-trick ball in the Ashes. Everyone knew Broad was stone dead - including Broad - and purely because he was the last batsman before the real tail he insisted it be referred. Which kind of pissed in my Cheerios, considering the occasion.

 

[Crazy Sam]

I hated listening to Mark Taylor on day 5 of the test. He went on and on about his DRS views (which I completely disagree with) all day.

 

[andyc]

So initially people said UDRS helps spinners because benefit of the doubt no longer goes to batsman esp. long stride etc. now people say UDRS helps batsmen because it's preventing umpires from giving wrong decisions. So where do people sit regarding UDRS at the end?

Isn't that the whole point of it though?

 

[LongHopCassidy]

Wade admits issues with focusing for long periods

Will be sponsored by Ritalin on the morrow, IMO.

 

[Pup Clarke]

Wade needs more meat imo - obviously surviving on leaves.

 

[Jono]

It was there to eliminate the howlers and nothing more.

This phrase (and the use of the word "howler") has become pretty cliche when talking about the UDRS, but is it actually true? When it was introduced was this the line used?

 

[hendrix]

I don't really mind strategic use of the DRS, as long as it's only 2 decisions per innings.

It adds another element to the game and I think it draws in the crowd a little bit.

It needs to be very clear how it works on big screens though so laypeople can understand what's going on.

 

[hendrix]

I hated listening to Mark Taylor on day 5 of the test. He went on and on about his DRS views (which I completely disagree with) all day.

Me too, was really frustrating because noone was putting up the other side of the coin.

The one thing I would change is that if any part of the ball pitches in line with any part of the wickets it should be umpires call.

 

[Spark]

Me too, was really frustrating because noone was putting up the other side of the coin.

The one thing I would change is that if any part of the ball pitches in line with any part of the wickets it should be umpires call.

This might be a good idea. I can't say I'm a hundred percent comfortable with a decision being automatically overturned because it pitched 2mm outside leg - though it may be accurate and true to the spirit of the law, it's definitely not why the system is in place

 

[Spark]

Australia v Sri Lanka, 2nd Test, Melbourne : Michael Clarke predicts more bowling for Matthew Wade | Cricket News | Australia v Sri Lanka | ESPN Cricinfo

"There are some opening bowlers around the world who struggle to reach the 132kph Matt generated"

What a captain.

 

[LongHopCassidy]

This phrase (and the use of the word "howler") has become pretty cliche when talking about the UDRS, but is it actually true? When it was introduced was this the line used?

Near enough. (Obligatory PDF warning)

Aim

To eliminate clear umpiring errors from Test cricket.

Which is about as emphatic wording as you'll get from the ICC.

 

[Spark]

In all the press releases/interviewers with Dave Richardson (the guy in charge of implementing UDRS and I think that's his name) he makes it clear that it's for getting rid of howlers as well.

 

[LongHopCassidy]

Australia v Sri Lanka, 2nd Test, Melbourne : Michael Clarke predicts more bowling for Matthew Wade | Cricket News | Australia v Sri Lanka | ESPN Cricinfo



What a captain.

Looked better than Hastings.

 

[Crazy Sam]

Malcolm Conn reckons Starc will be rested for the MCG test and brought back in for Sydney. Siddle, Johnson, Bird all to play.

 

[Spikey]

starc being rested from sydney would probably make more sense but w/evr

 

[NUFAN]

FFS. Seriously Starc rested? He is resting right now, lets try and win the series first before giving any tom dick or johnson a game.

 

[benchmark00]

When are we going to learn re: Johnson? How many spells of short and wide **** does he have to bowl to be black listed?

I blame Dennis Lillee.

 

[Tangles]

I don't like this rest policy either. I hope Siddle and Lyon are ready to bowl a lot. With Bird on debut and Johnson in the team they might be busy. Johnson did look more accurate in Perth but it was at a the cost of his pace which was the only reason he used to get wickets anyway.

 

[Migara]

Sri Lanka in Australia 2012-13 : Last-day pitch a 'minefield' - SL coach | Cricket News | Australia v Sri Lanka | ESPN Cricinfo

This is such bull****:



a) it was never a minefield. Sure, the ball stayed low outside off stump a couple of times, but that's not unexpected on a 5 day wicket.

b) Score your runs in the first innings like Aus did and it's not unfair.

If this ws at Galle instead of Hobart, plenty of people will be calling for curators head.