Brumbeh's Pitchers

[benchmark00]

I would like Brumbeh to post all the players he considers to have 'questionable actions', and next to these names I'd like him to rate them from 1-10, 1 being a clean action and 10 being a filthy, unadulterated chuck.




Will be disappointed if a parody thread called 'Brumbeh's Pictures' doesn't show up in the testing forum within the next 24 hours.

 

[Daemon]

ricky ponting 10

 

[BoyBrumby]

Hey, don't stereotype me. I'm a fully rounded individual who doesn't focus on particular hobbyhorses...

Nah, I'll bite:

Inzy - 11
Ajmal - 10
Botha - 10
Shabbir - 10
Gannon - 9
Samuels - 9
Williamson - 9
Shoaib Malik - 8.5
Jermaine Lawson - 8
Murali - 8
Kirtley - 6.5
Hall - 6
Hafeez - 5
Lee - 3.5
Shoaib - 3
Praveen - 2
Ashwin - 1.5

& obviously chaps like Tony Lock and Gordon Rorke (he of the 12 yard drag) from days of yore were filthy too.

 

[benchmark00]

A fine effort. I expect this thread to be updated regularly.

 

[Prensel]

Amla?

 

[Satyanash89]

amla?

12

 

[Jamee999]

Hey, don't stereotype me. I'm a fully rounded individual who doesn't focus on particular hobbyhorses...

Nah, I'll bite:

Inzy - 11
Ajmal - 10
Botha - 10
Shabbir - 10
Gannon - 9
Samuels - 9
Williamson - 9
Shoaib Malik - 8.5
Jermaine Lawson - 8
Murali - 8
Kirtley - 6.5
Hall - 6
Hafeez - 5
Lee - 3.5
Shoaib - 3
Praveen - 2
Ashwin - 1.5

& obviously chaps like Tony Lock and Gordon Rorke (he of the 12 yard drag) from days of yore were filthy too.

Confirmed chucker.

 

[Pup Clarke]

Amla?

Take it to the 'Brumbeh's Bearded XI' thread.

 

[Prince EWS]

Brumby to make a post about how Amla actually has a ****house beard.

 

[Top_Cat]

No McGrath?

 

[benchmark00]

 

[LongHopCassidy]

Dean Jones a disgusting chucker too. Just ask the edge of the 1986 Chennai pitch.

 

[Furball]

Brumby to make a post about how Amla actually has a ****house beard.

He's not wrong on that one either.

 

[Top_Cat]

Dean Jones a disgusting chucker too. Just ask the edge of the 1986 Chennai pitch.

Worse is how much chucking Jones induces in others talking about that knock, tbh.

 

[JBMAC]

Hey, don't stereotype me. I'm a fully rounded individual who doesn't focus on particular hobbyhorses...

Nah, I'll bite:

Inzy - 11
Ajmal - 10
Botha - 10
Shabbir - 10
Gannon - 9
Samuels - 9
Williamson - 9
Shoaib Malik - 8.5
Jermaine Lawson - 8
Murali - 8
Kirtley - 6.5
Hall - 6
Hafeez - 5
Lee - 3.5
Shoaib - 3
Praveen - 2
Ashwin - 1.5

& obviously chaps like Tony Lock and Gordon Rorke (he of the 12 yard drag) from days of yore were filthy too.

Surprised you have not included Griffith (10),

 

[Jono]

Hey, don't stereotype me. I'm a fully rounded individual who doesn't focus on particular hobbyhorses...

Nah, I'll bite:

Inzy - 11
Ajmal - 10
Botha - 10
Shabbir - 10
Gannon - 9
Samuels - 9
Williamson - 9
Shoaib Malik - 8.5
Jermaine Lawson - 8
Murali - 8
Kirtley - 6.5
Hall - 6
Hafeez - 5
Lee - 3.5
Shoaib - 3
Praveen - 2
Ashwin - 1.5

& obviously chaps like Tony Lock and Gordon Rorke (he of the 12 yard drag) from days of yore were filthy too.

I would have thought Murali is either 0 or 10. Can you explain the 8? Why is he not worse than Malik, Botha etc.?

 

[Daemon]

Mills and Harbhajan solid 6s imo

 

[Jono]

Yeah Mills is fairly uggo.

Harbhajan too.

 

[Flem274*]

Andy Ellis - 12

imo

 

[BoyBrumby]

I would have thought Murali is either 0 or 10. Can you explain the 8? Why is he not worse than Malik, Botha etc.?

Well he does have the unique genetics so have adjusted accordingly.

Don't buy that he's 0 or 10 tho. The fact that some deliveries looked worse than others suggests he sometimes put a little more "work" on the ball than others.