• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Taboo Draft

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
It's all very complicated, because Cabinet96 wasn't skipped, he picked incorrectly, and as far as I know picking incorrectly doesn't mean the next guy can now pick, unless the deadline is up.
The deadline was then up though wasn't it? That means Hoe has to pick based on what was before him ignoring cabinet.
 

G.I.Joe

International Coach
Actually Hoe's cheated here hasn't he? With Cabinet skipped he can't pick a batsman or a keeper, so he can't take KP.
He wasn't skipped when I picked. Although I was incorrect to act under the assumption that Cabinet would correct his pick immediately. As things are now, yeah, I can't pick KP.
 

G.I.Joe

International Coach
It's all very complicated, because Cabinet96 wasn't skipped, he picked incorrectly, and as far as I know picking incorrectly doesn't mean the next guy can now pick, unless the deadline is up. So, G. I Joe has either, picked before his go, or made an incorrect pick and we have to rollback, because his taboos were Arthur Morris (Batsman) & Jeffrey Dujon (Wicket Keeper).

However, I assume G.I Joe made his pick assuming Cabinet96 would be picking a pacer once he came back on, so his taboos, in his mind, were Dujon (Wicket Keeper) and (y) (Pacer). So that means, Eds taboo's should be Cabinet96's (pacer) and G. I. Joe's (batsman), but when Eds' pick commenced they were - possibly - Jager's Dujon (Wicket Keeper) & Kevin Pietersen (Batsman), because Cabinet96 hadn't made his pick yet.....but then G. I Joe assumed that Cabinet96 had picked a paceman but just not named him yet....arahghhfuewgi.

So I'm not quite sure what the **** we should do. We could rollback to G. I Joe, in which case he picks KP because he can now, and then Eds' tab00 is Cabinet96's (pacer) and G. I. Joe's (batsman) and then NUFAN's tab00s are G. I. Joe's (batsman) & Eds' allrounder/spinner/wicket keeper. Or...we could just shut our eyes and overlook this whole mess, in which case 8ankitj is up and his tab00's are Ed's pacer and NUFAN's spinner
That's what's happened. As things turned out Cabinet didn't correct his pick in time, so technically he's got to be skipped. Which means my pick was an incorrect one too.

So Eds then had to act under the assumption that both Cabinet and I were skipped, and his pick worked out fine seen that way.

NUFAN had to act under the assumption that Cabinet (incorrect pick), me (incorrect pick) and Eds (timed out) were all skipped, and his pick works out fine too.

It's Cabinet and I that need to remake picks based on the actual taboos.
 

G.I.Joe

International Coach
I'm picking Shakib Al Hasan (All Rounder)

Winnie Taboos

Aubrey Faulkner
Shakib Al Hasan
Andrew Flintoff
Dale Steyn
Neil Adcock
Muttiah Muralitharan
 

Cabinet96

Hall of Fame Member
I say we just overlook the whole mess. As has been mentioned Joe picked someone he new would be available once I picked. The way it is actually looks cleaner overall and I think we'd be better of staying how we are.

If, however, you want me to change my pick, I will. In which case, who can't I pick?
 

Cevno

Hall of Fame Member
Was my fault too, tbh. I didn't realize that Joe was waiting for cabinet to correct his pick as it was wrong and told him it was his pick.
 

G.I.Joe

International Coach
Is it my turn? What am I allowed to pick?
Anyone but a spinner or keeper.

Cabinet, myself, Eds are considered skipped.

8ankitj and Cevno have also had their windows expired, but this was a result of them holding off till the mess was cleared. So lets pretend the 24 hours since NUFAN picked don't matter, and that 8ankitj gets his go now. It's now 1.5 hours since 8ankitj was up.

Cevno will pick after 8ankitj, and unless 8ankitj is skipped, Cevno's taboos will be whatever NUFAN and 8ankitj will have picked.
 

G.I.Joe

International Coach
Round 1
marc71178 - Garfield Sobers (All Rounder)
Uvelocity - Shane Warne (Spinner)
Cabinet96 - Adam Gilchrist (Wicket Keeper)
Spikey - Jacques Kallis (Batsman)
Cevno - Imran Khan (All Rounder)
Pothas - Malcolm Marshall (Pacer)
G.I.Joe - Muttiah Muralitharan (Spinner)
kyear2 - Viv Richards (Batsman)
kingkallis - Richard Hadlee (All Rounder)
Himannv - Sydney Barnes (Pacer)
weeman27bob - Jack Hobbs (Batsman)
Jager - Keith Miller (All Rounder)
8ankitj - Curtly Ambrose (Pacer)
morgieb - Sachin Tendulkar (Batsman)
Eds - Ian Botham (All Rounder)
Blakus - Bill O'Reilly (Spinner)
NUFAN - Fred Trueman (Pacer)
Valer -Walter Hammond (Batsman)
Marcuss -Clarrie Grimmett (Spinner)
Zaremba - Glenn McGrath (Pacer)
weldone - Brian Lara (Batsman)
Michaelf7777777 - Andy Flower (Wicket Keeper)

Round 2
weldone - Alan Davidson (Pacer)
Michaelf7777777 - Shaun Pollock (Allrounder)
Zaremba - Jim Laker (Spinner)
Marcuss - Wasim Akram (Pacer)
Valer - Georger Headley (Batsman)
NUFAN - Wilfred Rhodes (All Rounder)
Blakus - Dennis Lillee (Pacer)
Eds - Victor Trumper (Batsman)
morgieb - Les Ames (Wicket Keeper)
8ankitj - Graeme Pollock (Batsman)
Jager - Richie Benaud (Spinner)
weeman27bob - Alan Knott (Wicket Keeper)
Himannv - Allan Donald (Pacer)
kingkallis - Len Hutton (Batsman)
kyear2 - Denis Lindsay (Wicket Keeper)
G.I.Joe - Aubrey Faulkner (All Rounder)
Pothas - Ray Lindwall (Pacer)
Cevno - Sunil Gavaskar (Batsman)
Spikey - Kapil Dev (All Rounder)
Cabinet96 - Waqar Younis (Pacer)
uvelocity - Rodney Marsh (Wicket Keeper)
marc71178 - Kumar Sangakkara (Batsman)

Round 3
kingkallis - Micheal Holding (Seamer)
weeman27bob - Hedley Verity (Spinner)
Zaremba Ricky Ponting (Batsman)
Himannv - Joel Garner (Pacer)
Eds - Trevor Goddard (All Rounder)
Valer - Herbert Sutcliffe (Batsman)
weldone - Courtney Walsh (Pacer)
Jager - Andy Roberts (Pacer)
Spikey - Anil Kumble (Spinner)
NUFAN - Greg Chappell (Batsman)
G.I.Joe - Dale Steyn (Pacer)
Michaelf7777777 - Chris Cairns (All Rounder)
Blakus - Barry Richards (Batsman)
8ankitj - John Waite (Wicket Keeper)
morgieb - Bob Willis (Pacer)
Marcuss - Steve Waugh (Batsman)
Cabinet96 - Tony Grieg (All Rounder)
Uvelocity - Shoaib Akhtar (Pacer)
Cevno - Sir Clyde Walcott (Batsman)
kyear2 - Derek Underwood (Spinner)
Pothas - Monty Noble (All Rounder)
marc71178 - Matt Prior (Keeper)

Round 4
Pothas - Everton Weekes (Batsman)
marc71178 - Jack Gregory (All Rounder)
kyear2 - Frank Tyson (Pacer)
Cevno - Ken Barrington (Batsman)
Uvelocity - Vinoo Mankad (All Rounder)
Cabinet96 - John Briggs (Spinner)
Marcuss - Geoff Boycott (Batsman)
morgieb - Brian Statham (Pacer)
8ankitj - Hugh Tayfield (Spinner)
Blakus - Allan Border (Batsman)
Michaelf7777777 - Mike Procter (Pacer)
G.I.Joe - Andrew Flintoff (All Rounder)
NUFAN - Frank Worrell (Batsman)
Spikey - Alec Bedser (Pacer)
Jager - Ian Healy (Keeper)
weldone - Rahul Dravid (Batsman)
Valer - Charlie Turner (Pacer)
Eds - Hugh Trumble (Spinner)
Himannv - Denis Compton (Batsman)
Zaremba - Jeff Thompson (Pacer)
weeman27bob - Lance Gibbs (Spinner)
kingkallis - Javed Miandad (Batsman)

Round 5

Valer - George Lohmann (Pacer)
marc71178 - Abdul Qadir (Spinner)
weldone - Neil Harvey (Batsman)
Blakus - Harold Larwood (Pacer)
Himannv - Subash Gupte (Spinner)
Zaremba - Mahela Jayawardene (Batsman)
weeman27bob - Wes Hall (Pacer)
Spikey - Alec Stewart (Wicket Keeper)
Cevno - WG Grace (Batsman)
8ankitj - Fred Spofforth (Pacer)
NUFAN - Farokh Engineer (Wicket Keeper)
Eds - Gordon Greenidge (Batsman)
G.I.Joe - Neil Adcock (Pacer)
Cabinet96 - Greame Swann (Spinner)
Jager - Peter May (Batsman)
kyear2 - Colin Croft (Pacer)
kingkallis - Bhagawath Chandrasekhar (Spinner)
Pothas - Stan McCabe (Batsman)
Uvelocity - Mohammad Asif (Pacer)
Marcuss - Jack Russel (Wicket Keeper)
morgieb - Matthew Hayden (Batsman)
Michaelf7777777 - Peter Pollock (Pacer)

Round 6

morgieb - Tony Lock (Spinner)
Michaelf7777777 - MS Dhoni (Wicketkeeper)
Marcuss - Dudley Nourse (Batsman)
Uvelocity - Chris Lewis (Pacer)
Pothas - Bishan Bedi (Spinner)
kingkallis - John Snow (Pacer)
kyear2 - Arthur Morris (Batsman)
Jager - Jeffrey Dujon (Wicket Keeper)
Cabinet96 - Jason Gillespie (Pacer)
G.I.Joe - Shakib Al Hasan (All Rounder)
Eds - Fazal Mahmood (Pacer)
NUFAN - Erapalli Prasanna (Spinner)
8ankitj
Cevno
Spikey
weeman27bob
Zaremba
Himannv
Blakus
weldone
marc71178
Valer
 
Last edited:

ankitj

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Virendra Sehwag (batsman)

Team so far:

Virendra Sehwag
Greame Pollock
John Waite +
Curtly Ambrose
Hugh Tayfield
Fred Spofforth
 
Last edited:

Spikey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
I've left my pick on G.I Joe's user page, in case Cenvo picks before I wake up, which I assume he will, but hope he won't because I want to pick a batsman damnit
 

Top