CW Player Ratings

[nick-o]

Here are the current averages for India v South Africa:

India

S Badrinath - 3.8
MS Dhoni - 7.2
Gautam Gambhir - 3.0
Harbhajan Singh - 7.8
Zaheer Khan - 7.8
VVS Laxman - 8
Amit Mishra - 4.8
WP Saha - 3.6
Virender Sehwag - 8.8
Ishant Sharma - 2.6
Sachin Tendulkar - 8.4
Murali Vijay - 2.8


South Africa

HM Amla - 10
MV Boucher - 6.25
AB de Villiers - 4
JP Duminy - 1.5
PL Harris - 5.8
JH Kallis - 7.4
M Morkel - 5.4
WD Parnell - 3.8
AN Petersen - 7.8
AG Prince - 2.75
GC Smith - 2.4
DW Steyn - 8.6

HM Amla gets the first perfect 10 of this experiment -- it would be even higher as a couple of people wanted to give him 10.5, but I've decided marks out of 10 mean 10 is the max.

There's some divergence in the ratings -- Mishra's high of 7 and low of 2 is quite a wide spread.

I'm still not sure if this is worth doing -- the response isn't as great as I'd hoped, and there's only been one response for New Zealand v Bangladesh (although maybe a one-off just shouldn't be considered as a series). But I'll try to keep it going a bit longer, so please post your scores if you have a chance.

Cheers

 

[Maximus0723]

Thanks nick.

 

[nick-o]

Another series completed, so I'll dust this off and drag it out again.

It'll be interesting to see if there's any improvement for Bangladesh this time round after what looked like a more competitive display, and how England's second team players measure up.

As always, copy the list and add your ratings; hope I've spelled these right...

Bangladesh

Abdur Razzak -
Aftab Ahmed -
Imrul Kayes -
Jahurul Islam -
Junaid Siddique -
Mahmudullah -
Mushfiqur Rahim -
Naeem Islam -
Rubel Hossain -
Shafiul Islam -
Shahadat Hossain -
Shakib Al Hasan -
Tamim Iqbal -


England

IR Bell -
TT Bresnan -
SCJ Broad -
MA Carberry -
PD Collingwood -
AN Cook -
ST Finn -
KP Pietersen -
MJ Prior -
GP Swann -
JC Tredwell -
IJL Trott -

 

[nick-o]

Just to confirm -- no one's interested in this, right? Time to chin up and pull the plug, innit?

Or post another set of teams and watch no one respond? Thought it was a good idea, myself, but evidently not.

 

[Maximus0723]

Just to confirm -- no one's interested in this, right? Time to chin up and pull the plug, innit?

Or post another set of teams and watch no one respond? Thought it was a good idea, myself, but evidently not.

It was/is brothah.

 

[Manee]

Just to confirm -- no one's interested in this, right? Time to chin up and pull the plug, innit?

Or post another set of teams and watch no one respond? Thought it was a good idea, myself, but evidently not.

It is an okay idea, but no one really cared about the Bangladesh and England series.